OndaGrande
Boudin rouge Level: 51
Posts: 328/505 EXP: 991707 For next: 22238
Since: 1.5.03 From: California, Home of THE LAKERS!
Since last post: 2663 days Last activity: 2227 days
| #1 Posted on 9.9.11 1928.30 Reposted on: 9.9.18 1929.00 | Thoughts from anyone? Eagles is great and deserves to be recognized especially considering PWI's position that WWE & TNA were doing little to elevate the validity of their Champions and rosters in general. Being kayfabe there are several wrestlers ,based on their abilities, deserving of either higher ranking or being on the list. But part of their criteria is exposure to the fans so in that context there is room for argument.Wrestlers I feel deserve to be ranked higher are Portia Perez, Nicole Matthews, Rachel Summerlynn, Jessica James, & Sassy Stephie.
1. Madison Eagles (Shimmer Champion. PWWA Champion. Chikara) 2. Mercedes Martinez (WSU Champion, Shimmer) 3. Mickie James (TNA Knockouts Champion) 4. Natalya (WWE) 5. Madison Rayne (TNA) 6. Cheerleader Melissa (Shimmer, RCW, NCWFF,NWA/ProWrestling Revolution, Chickfight) 7. Beth Phoenix (WWE) 8. Tara (TNA Knockouts Tag Team Champion) 9. MsChif (Shimmer,AAW) 10. Sara Del Rey (Shimmer, ROH, ArenaChicks, Chikara) 11. Eve Torres (WWE) 12. Angelina Love (TNA) 13. Layla (WWE) 14. Sarita (TNA) 15. Kelly Kelly (WWE Divas Champion) 16. Serena Deeb (Shimmer, WSU, SMASH) 17. Velvet Sky (TNA) 18. Ayako Hamada (Shimmer) 19. LuFisto (SHIMMER, NCWFF) 20. Winter (TNA, W.I.L.D. Champion) 21. Brie Bella (WWE) 22. Angel Orsini (WSU, ArenaChicks) 23. Melina (former WWE, WSU) 24. Daizee Haze (Shimmer, ROH, Chikara) 25. Nikki Roxx (Shimmer, NECW) 26. Gail Kim (WWE) 27. Jazz (WSU, ArenaChicks) 28. Maryse (WWE) 29. Christina Von Eerie (Shimmer, AAA, ACW-TX, NWA/Hollywood, PWG) 30. Portia Perez (Shimmer, ACW-TX, Chikara) 31. Rosita (TNA) 32. ODB (TNA) 33. Nicole Matthews (Shimmer, ECCW) 34. Rachel Summerlyn (Shimmer, ACW-TX) 35. Jessicka Havok (WSU, AIW) 36. Brittany Force (Shimmer, ArenaChicks, AIW) 37. Kellie Skater (Shimmer, PWWA) 38. Tina San Antonio (WSU) 39. Melanie Cruise (POWW Tag Team Champion, Shimmer) 40. Cherry Bomb (NCWFF) 41. Sassy Stephie (WSU Spirit Champion,Shimmer, ArenaChicks, AIW) 42. Tasha Simone ( NWA Ladies Champion) 43. Alicia Fox (WWE) 44. Amber O'Neal (ArenaChicks, CWF, WSU) 45. Allison Danger (Shimmer, NWA/Hollywood, ArenaChicks, Chickfight) 46. Kacee Carlisle (WSU, NECW) 47. Brittany Savage (WSU) 48. A.J. (WWE) 49. Melissa Coates (WSU) 50. Jessica James (ACW-TX American Joshi Champion, Shimmer)
(edited by OndaGrande on 10.9.11 1116) Promote this thread! | | odessasteps
Scrapple Level: 140
Posts: 4483/5065 EXP: 32483424 For next: 803063
Since: 2.1.02 From: MD, USA
Since last post: 3571 days Last activity: 3538 days
| #2 Posted on 9.9.11 2037.01 Reposted on: 9.9.18 2038.08 | Odd they mention Chikara for Eagles and Daizee but not SDR. | yamcharulez
Mettwurst Level: 32
Posts: 66/165 EXP: 190948 For next: 15496
Since: 6.1.02 From: chicago
Since last post: 2159 days Last activity: 1257 days
| #3 Posted on 9.9.11 2339.10 Reposted on: 9.9.18 2347.22 | I find it wrong that Layla, Eve and Kelly Kelly are listed higher then the Canadian Ninjas ( Portia Perez and Nicole Matthews) and Rachel Summerlynn who are all in the 30's | Tyler Durden
Landjager Level: 65
Posts: 600/885 EXP: 2255546 For next: 80094
Since: 22.2.04 From: Frankfurt, Germany
Since last post: 1281 days Last activity: 1211 days
| #4 Posted on 10.9.11 0931.19 Reposted on: 10.9.18 0931.25 | Sara Del Rey should be higher. She's one of my favourite female wrestlers right now and of all time. But maybe she hasn't done a lot lately? Or has she? Why doesn't the E sign her? | wannaberockstar
Frankfurter Level: 61
Posts: 285/745 EXP: 1825172 For next: 51435
Since: 7.3.02
Since last post: 2735 days Last activity: 198 days
| #5 Posted on 10.9.11 1058.59 Reposted on: 10.9.18 1059.01 | Madison Rayne and Mickie James above Sara Del Ray and Kelly Kelly is in the top 15? :/
Originally posted by Tyler Durden Sara Del Rey should be higher. She's one of my favourite female wrestlers right now and of all time. But maybe she hasn't done a lot lately? Or has she? Why doesn't the E sign her?
Because she can wrestle? ;) | Llakor
Landjager Level: 67
Posts: 805/930 EXP: 2555806 For next: 37080
Since: 2.1.02 From: Montreal, Quebec, CANADA
Since last post: 4005 days Last activity: 3996 days
| #6 Posted on 10.9.11 1223.45 Reposted on: 10.9.18 1225.13 | Just as a reality check, Cherry Bomb is AWFUL.
She wouldn't even make my Top 10 of the Quebec girls (NCWFF) | lotjx
Scrapple Level: 129
Posts: 1984/4785 EXP: 24951184 For next: 98537
Since: 5.9.08
Since last post: 1681 days Last activity: 1520 days
| #7 Posted on 10.9.11 1315.40 Reposted on: 10.9.18 1317.57 | I little surprised an Indy won it. Usual PWI goes a little more Kayfabe and gives it to one of the Divas who can barely wrestler. It is a shame that you go through this list and see Sara, Cheerleader Melissa and other female wrestlers who are great wrestlers that not on TV right now for whatever reasons. TNA really need to keep Melissa and go with more indy girls then getting old WWE rejects. | Tenken347
Knackwurst Level: 115
Posts: 1840/3258 EXP: 16317858 For next: 493557
Since: 27.2.03 From: Parts Unknown
Since last post: 41 days Last activity: 3 days
| #8 Posted on 10.9.11 1324.32 Reposted on: 10.9.18 1325.04 | Obviously, there are a lot of problems with this list, but what I don't understand is, how is Brie Bella number 21, but Nikki Bella isn't even on the list? There's no way you can tell me that there's such a gap in talent between the two of them that this placement on the list makes any sense. | dMp
Knackwurst Level: 111
Posts: 2267/3003 EXP: 14827869 For next: 40537
Since: 4.1.02 From: The Hague, Netherlands (Europe)
Since last post: 265 days Last activity: 12 hours
| #9 Posted on 10.9.11 1605.38 Reposted on: 10.9.18 1606.46 | Originally posted by Tenken347 Obviously, there are a lot of problems with this list, but what I don't understand is, how is Brie Bella number 21, but Nikki Bella isn't even on the list? There's no way you can tell me that there's such a gap in talent between the two of them that this placement on the list makes any sense.
Wasn't Brie the champion? So probably she has wrestled a lot more in the past year than Nikki. And maybe she was the one who also picked up the wins when they did their twin-magic. That would mean she deserves to be higher than her sister
Obviously I have no clue. Also, I don't watch Shimmer so I don't know many of these women or how talented they are, but I always thought that Sara Del Rey is an easy top-5 pick for any list. | Mr. Boffo
Scrapple Level: 124
Posts: 3557/3844 EXP: 21369166 For next: 467496
Since: 24.3.02 From: Oshkosh, WI
Since last post: 3895 days Last activity: 3856 days
| #10 Posted on 10.9.11 2133.25 Reposted on: 10.9.18 2134.29 | Yeah, Brie held the Diva's Title for 70 days during the the time period.
Also, I was extremely bored, so I watched every match involving the Bella Twins that was on WWE.com. From July 1, 2010 to June 30, 2011: Nikki went 2-5 in singles matches. Brie went 4-1 in singles matches. The two of them went 6-3 in tag team matches. The two of them went 6-2 when involved in a >2 person tag team. And individually, Nikki won a Diva's Battle Royal, but Brie won two tag team matches in which Nikki was not an official participant.
So yeah, from the standings it does appear that Brie is more talented. Or knowing that they win every match by Twin Magic, maybe we can say that Nikki is the real brains behind it, because she's done much better at helping Brie win than vice versa. | CHAPLOW
Morcilla Level: 55
Posts: 488/617 EXP: 1305631 For next: 8567
Since: 14.5.04 From: right behind you
Since last post: 3572 days Last activity: 2809 days
| #11 Posted on 11.9.11 0135.51 Reposted on: 11.9.18 0136.21 | Man, alls Im sayin is they need to get rid of that butterfly belt...
also Gail Kim is still in WWE? | CEOIII
Bockwurst Level: 55
Posts: 306/589 EXP: 1271869 For next: 42329
Since: 25.7.02 From: Franklin, PA
Since last post: 2600 days Last activity: 1936 days
| #12 Posted on 11.9.11 0434.54 Reposted on: 11.9.18 0434.56 | Originally posted by CHAPLOW Man, alls Im sayin is they need to get rid of that butterfly belt...
also Gail Kim is still in WWE?
*nods* Bailed early on a Diva battle royal, wants her release, WWE isn't giving it to her, so she's sitting on her ass at home instead of helping Beth and Natalya on their crusade. | Moss
Summer sausage Level: 45
Posts: 228/431 EXP: 628534 For next: 31635
Since: 23.9.10 From: Calgary, AB
Since last post: 3453 days Last activity: 3436 days
| #13 Posted on 12.9.11 2255.35 Reposted on: 12.9.18 2257.12 | Originally posted by dMp Wasn't Brie the champion? So probably she has wrestled a lot more in the past year than Nikki. And maybe she was the one who also picked up the wins when they did their twin-magic. That would mean she deserves to be higher than her sister
Might wanna re-read Tenken347's post as he never suggested she shouldn't, just that it makes no sense Brie's #21 and Nikki's at most #51.
Is there another woman named Eve Torres who works for WWE? Because the one I know isn't in Gail Kim's league, let alone more than twice as good. I'll also assume the same with Alicia Fox, as the one I know can't even hit her own finishing move half the time. And acts exactly the same after turning babyface that she did as a heel. 4 better than AJ...to quote The Situation, ARE YOU SERIOUS BRO?
Obvs Kaitlyn should be #1 ;) | Torchslasher
Knackwurst Level: 117
Posts: 2955/3369 EXP: 17605478 For next: 242470
Since: 17.1.02 From: South F’n Carolina
Since last post: 45 days Last activity: 3 days
| #14 Posted on 14.9.11 0051.37 Reposted on: 14.9.18 0056.51 | I will assume that Lacey Von Erich is 51.
Where is Glory on this list? | TwisterF5
Italian Level: 37
Posts: 225/243 EXP: 324618 For next: 13638
Since: 18.2.04 From: The Houston 'burbs
Since last post: 3483 days Last activity: 3007 days
| #15 Posted on 14.9.11 0701.25 Reposted on: 14.9.18 0702.03 | I don't know if this list comprises of the women that are currently active, or a list of those that were active at all during 2011. If the latter, then Michelle McCool should be somewhere on there. | spf
Scrapple Level: 144
Posts: 5188/5410 EXP: 35857889 For next: 852505
Since: 2.1.02 From: The Las Vegas of Canada
Since last post: 3069 days Last activity: 404 days
| #16 Posted on 14.9.11 1526.58 Reposted on: 14.9.18 1528.31 | I would point out that I look like a prophet based on my first impression of seeing Madison Eagles live, but then I'd have to take responsibility for speaking ill of Jessie McKay and that would be terrible.
Originally posted by me back in 2008 Madison Eagles was a revelation. Her partner was sort of dead weight, but Eagles is 6 feet tall, strong, and incredibly athletic. Perhaps the best comparison I can make is that she reminded me of a female Mike Awesome when he appeared in ECW back in 1998. She flew around the ring, moving with speed that you wouldn't dream of from a girl that big. I really hope that they can get over to these shores on a regular basis, and think TNA would be very well served to look at Eagles. The result was really secondary for me compared to how blown away I was by her performance.
http://the-w.com/thread.php/id=36667
For those of you who would like to see the #1 female worker according to PWI (and #2, #6, #9, #10, and about 15 more listed) SHIMMER is running again on October 1st and 2nd in Berwyn, IL. I cannot recommend these shows enough. For $30 a day you get 6 hours of the best female wrestlers from around the world.
Also Kellie Skater should be given her own ranking as the awesomest person in the world, transcending mundane numeric ranking systems. But that's just one man's opinion. | drjayphd
Scrapple Moderator Level: 126
Posts: 3782/4035 EXP: 22940269 For next: 143898
Since: 22.4.02 From: New Hampshire
Since last post: 766 days Last activity: 350 days
| ICQ: | |
| Y!: | |
|
| #17 Posted on 14.9.11 2212.06 Reposted on: 14.9.18 2213.04 | Aloisia/Isis the Amazon was so rocket pissed about her omission she torched another four bridges. | Torchslasher
Knackwurst Level: 117
Posts: 2958/3369 EXP: 17605478 For next: 242470
Since: 17.1.02 From: South F’n Carolina
Since last post: 45 days Last activity: 3 days
| #18 Posted on 15.9.11 0132.49 Reposted on: 15.9.18 0134.49 | Originally posted by spf I would point out that I look like a prophet based on my first impression of seeing Madison Eagles live, but then I'd have to take responsibility for speaking ill of Jessie McKay and that would be terrible.
Originally posted by me back in 2008 Madison Eagles was a revelation. Her partner was sort of dead weight, but Eagles is 6 feet tall, strong, and incredibly athletic. Perhaps the best comparison I can make is that she reminded me of a female Mike Awesome when he appeared in ECW back in 1998. She flew around the ring, moving with speed that you wouldn't dream of from a girl that big. I really hope that they can get over to these shores on a regular basis, and think TNA would be very well served to look at Eagles. The result was really secondary for me compared to how blown away I was by her performance.
I told you then about McKay. Of course I don't see her on this list, and I have lost track of her, so I don't know if she warrants a spot on the list this year. | spf
Scrapple Level: 144
Posts: 5190/5410 EXP: 35857889 For next: 852505
Since: 2.1.02 From: The Las Vegas of Canada
Since last post: 3069 days Last activity: 404 days
| #19 Posted on 15.9.11 1002.10 Reposted on: 15.9.18 1003.48 | Originally posted by Torchslasher I told you then about McKay. Of course I don't see her on this list, and I have lost track of her, so I don't know if she warrants a spot on the list this year.
You were totally right about McKay. Her series of matches with Nicole Matthews has been excellent, and her SHIMMER title match with Eagles earlier this year was awesome. I'm guessing that she is one of those who because she didn't do much in the US just didn't get considered this year, but her work in SHIMMER has been top-notch since she started working singles. | ALL ORIGINAL POSTS IN THIS THREAD ARE NOW AVAILABLE |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |