So here's how we chose the albums for the All-TIME 100. We researched and listened and agonized until we had a list of the greatest and most influential records ever - and then everyone complained because there was no Pink Floyd on it.
And that's exactly how it should be. We hope you'll treat the All-TIME 100 as a great musical parlor game. Read and listen to the arguments for the selections, then tell us what we missed or got wrong. Or even possibly what we got right.
And nice of them to provide a poll! har har
Which of these albums should have made the All-Time 100?
Pink Floyd, Dark Side of the Moon The Band, Music From Big Pink Jay-Z, Reasonable Doubt The Doors, The Doors Superfly, Curtis Mayfield This Year's Model, Elvis Costello Dusty in Memphis, Dusty Springfield Appetite for Destruction, Guns N' Roses
* * * * *
Decent write ups on the 100 list. Audio features are available as well. The writers sure don't think much of the modern music scene (2000s). The "greatest hits" compilations equaling "greatest albums" seems a bit odd, but it's ELVIS, so I'm not arguing, much
Demonstrations are a drag. Besides, we're much too high
Say what you want about the sicko freak, but Michael Jackson's THRILLER is hands down, one of the top 15 best albums ever produced; and with this list missing it, I call "Shenanigains!
EDIT: I also agree with the hits comps being counted as cheating. It's like saying that the original albums were for shit, but if you get to pick and choose songs from those albums and make a new album, that's ok.
...also, there's no way in fucking hell that REM's DOCUMENT is better then MURMER... that's crazy talk.
...and what's all the love for Pink Floyd? Sure they had some great songs, but listening to thier albums straight through is a jumbled mess. Even DARK SIDE.
EDIT 2!: Well, I'm just blind, I guess, because THRILLER was there and I missed it. ...strange.
If Appetite for Destruction only makes the maybe list, its wrong. The fact there is no Smashing Pumpkins makes it wrong. Using compilations 40 years after original release makes it wrong. Usinge people I've never heard makes it wrong.
THE TOP SELLERS 1. It's The Girls (The W at Amazon) Bette Midler (WB) 2. Storytone (Orchestral + Solo 2-CD Set) [Double CD] Neil Young (Reprise) 3. The Basement Tapes Complete: The Bootleg Series Vol. 11(Deluxe Edition) [Box set] Bob Dylan (Legacy) 4.