The W
Views: 134190237
Main | FAQ | Search: Y! / G | Calendar | Color chart | Log in for more!
24.6.18 1937
The W - Movies & TV - Smallville 10x4 - "Homecoming"
This thread has 18 referrals leading to it
Register and log in to post!
Thread rated: 4.08
Pages: 1
(2325 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
Post (3 total)
John Orquiola

Since: 28.2.02
From: Boston

Since last post: 1457 days
Last activity: 1457 days
#1 Posted on

SUPERMAN! (No, for real. SUPERMAN!)
TESS MERCER (Not this week)
Special DC Universe Guest Star:
plus a reference to:
SUPERGIRL! (A magazine cover with a photo taken of Kara from last week)
and a random mention of:
THE FLASH! (Lois, in reference to her relationship with Oliver Queen said, "It was quick. Like a Flash.")

"Homecoming" is Smallville's 200th episode. For my money, it is also, thus far, the best episode of Smallville ever. There's Absolute Justice, there's the Legion of Superheroes episode, there's the season 2 episode when Christopher Reeve appeared, but I say "Homecoming" trumps them all. This episode made me incredibly happy.

We saw him. We saw Superman. In an amazing and unexpected payoff to the opening scene of last season's finale that takes place in the future - 2017, according to the date on the Daily Planet (and hey, a major metropolitan newspaper is still in business seven years from now according to Smallville) - Clark time travels and meets Lois and more importantly, himself. Big laugh when Clark looks over his future self wearing a suit and glasses: "When did I get so uptight and nerdy?" And then our Clark gets to gaze out the window and watch as a familiar red cape streaks by and uses Superspeed flight to quell a nuclear explosion(!) in the horizon.

THEN they directly reference Superman: The Movie by having Lois in a helicopter accident atop the Daily Planet, which our Clark prevents (complete with Lois knocking out the pilot so he doesn't see it's Clark and protecting his identity). That's not all, "Homecoming" even directly references Superman Returns at the very end when Lois and Clark are slow dancing and she places her feet onto his, just like Kate Bosworth did Brandon Routh.

The gimmick of Brainiac 5 coming back from the 31st century to shake Clark loose of his malaise via time travel worked really well. This was preceded by an amusing throw away of the insane Smallville High counselor preparing to attack Clark in the same vein as all the super villains from the early seasons, only for Brainiac to lobotomize her and prevent it. Later, one of Clark's earliest season one enemies, the bug boy, tells Lois as Clark looks on non-corporeally that Clark's saving him way back when was the big difference-maker in his life, and the same with many others. No time for Freak of the Week. This is a new Smallville. There's bigger fish to fry.

The main theme of this episode is letting go. For Clark, it's to finally stop blaming himself for all the terrible things that have happened since Jonathan Kent died. And for Smallville the series itself, it's to radically reconceptualize who Clark is. Literally meeting himself seven years from now and letting him actually see who he will be is an interesting creative gambit. The series had dug Clark in such a deep hole where it was often so hard to believe he could ever be Superman that they've actually had the character not believe it himself for a couple of years. But now Clark has literally met Superman and wants to be that guy. Clark was really impressed by himself.

Then there's flying. Clark's malaise, self-doubt, and 'the darkness' within him, were all but spelled out as the reason he can't fly. As we were told a few too many times in this episode, letting go of all of that angst is what will get Clark to be Superman. (Superman is not about angst, Mr. Singer.) Slow dancing with Lois and both of them finally exchanging "I love yous", plus Clark focusing on what he has in the moment instead of regrets of the past and fear of tomorrow finally let him... well, float. Hover. But it's a start.

Even before the full-on Superman goodness of 2017, "Homecoming" was a tremendous mix of nostalgia and comedy. Lois' insistence on going to the Smallville High 5 year reunion because she was an alumni (for 23 days, a fact both Clark and I forgot) lead to a very funny runner where Lois knew everyone's name but no one knew who she was. The way she leaps effortlessly from comedy to neurosis to sweetness, I think Erica Durance is the MVP of this series at this point. She is simply the best Lois Lane ever.

A couple of heartwarming flashbacks where we saw Lana and Chloe from season one were surprisingly effective. (No Pete Ross or Lex Luthor mentioned at all.) Also a nice touch was Clark and Lois meeting the two kids who now run the Smallville High Torch in its current digital format, their hero worship of Chloe, and Chloe texting them her approval "from beyond the grave".

Plus Clark finally gave Oliver the tacit approval Oliver has always craved as Oliver gives his first one on one interview post "I am Green Arrow!" announcement.

By acknowledging their past and putting it where it belongs, behind them, what "Homecoming" announced was that the game is afoot, and that game is Turn Clark Kent Into Superman. Clark wants to be the man he saw as the hero of Metropolis in 2017. He wants to be the Man of Tomorrow.

For the first time in ten years of watching Smallville, I now really believe he's going to be Superman.

Best. Smallville. Ever. (So far.)

Promote this thread!
The Guinness.
Potato korv

Since: 24.4.05
From: San Diego, CA

Since last post: 40 days
Last activity: 16 hours
#2 Posted on | Instant Rating: 3.94
Excellent episode!

Was that a successful continuity tie-in to an earlier-in-the-series episode? Didn't Clark fly (float) once when dreaming of Lana. When he woke up he dropped a foot or so back to the bed? The continuity being the cause of how he was floating. Seems to be an internal thing (as indicated in this episode). Kinda a Peter Pan in "Hook think Happy thoughts concept.

Since: 5.9.08

Since last post: 4 days
Last activity: 4 days
#3 Posted on | Instant Rating: 1.66
I have to agree it is one of the better episodes. It reminded me of a Christmas Carol with Brainiac as the ghosts. The show is very good when it deals with just Lois and Clark. The actors have a lot of chemistry and its better written. Erica is the MVP of the show, because there have been so many episodes that were utter shit saved only by her presence and dialogue. I loved the flashbacks from episode one to Johnathan's Death. They really did throw the emo Clark out the window while setting him on fire. I just wish this was done in season 7 or 8, yet its better now then never.

The one thing that I did absolutely love was Ollie's speech. This is what it should have been instead the Iron man rip-off. The criticism of a generation of blogger critics is dead on. I am glad they are showing how heroes will be treated in the current cynical for the sake of being cynical media environment. I am sure Ollie outing himself will backfire at some point, but it was good for him or at least someone to say, "Hey, just because the rest of society is too lazy to do something, I am not."

Overall, this really probably saved this season from being another 15 episodes of stalling for him to put on the suit. The real question is can they keep this going like did with Absolute Justice to the finale with a hiccup here or there or will be another Legion where its one good episode followed by a series of disastrous episodes? I just hope Jo'rel this doesn't prove everything that Jo'rel said in the premiere right.

(edited by lotjx on 16.10.10 0837)
Thread rated: 4.08
Pages: 1
Thread ahead: South Park S14E09 - Its a Jersey Thing
Next thread: Marvel and ABC developing new Hulk TV series
Previous thread: Conan has his sidekick back
(2325 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
Clever or way too much time on one's hands. This was a good chuckle though (for those interested in high school level type myself). Youtube also has Top Gun 2: Brokeback Squadron.
- The Guinness., Btokeback to the Future (2006)
Related threads: Smallville 10x3 - "Supergirl" - Aquaman AND Mera on Smallville. - Smallville 10x1 (Lazarus) - More...
The W - Movies & TV - Smallville 10x4 - "Homecoming"Register and log in to post!

The W™ message board

©2001-2018 Brothers Zim

This old hunk of junk rendered your page in 0.243 seconds.