ROLL CALL: SUPERMAN! ULTRAMAN! LOIS LANE! LOIS LANE! TESS MERCER! TESS LUTHOR! THE GREEN ARROW! OLIVER QUEEN! Special Guest Stars: LIONEL LUTHOR! and EARTH-2!
Earth-2! Earth-effin'-2! Smallville finally tackles the parallel Universe idea in its tenth and final season with another series-best episode. "Luthor" was as tremendous an episode of Smallville as there ever was, not just for it's dizzying comic book concepts, but for the depth of emotional drama from our beloved heroes, with Tom Welling, Erica Durance, Cassidy Freeman, and Julian John Glover (he's back!) raising their performances to the next level.
Yet another evil version of Clark appears on Smallville (it's happened so often, Lois automatically guesses it's "a red-K" attack) but this one might be the best evil Clark of all. This is Clark Luthor, who, on the color-drained world of Earth-2, was rocketed to Earth from the doomed world of Krypton and found not by a couple of loving farmers, but by Lionel Luthor, who expected "the traveler's" arrival as part of Veritas.
Lionel raised Clark (and still named him Clark? A name Martha Kent picked? Hmm.) as his own son, alongside his real son Lex and his daughter from another mother Lu(Tess)a. And raise Clark Lionel did, into a homicidal (but sharply dressed) manic who sleeps with random floozies and torments the denizens of Metropolis as Ultraman. (Hey, Clark Luthor is pretty cool! But Earth-2 Oliver Queen is right on: the name "Ultraman" sucks.) No one knows Clark Luthor is Ultraman; he terrorizes Metropolis as a murderous blur and kills anyone who sees his face. Ultraman killed Earth-2's Lex (and the Swans) and carries on a sexual affair with Lionel's red-headed stepchild Tess. (We get a taste of the sexual chemistry between Tom Welling and Cassidy Freeman, and it's pretty super.) Maybe the most awesome concept is that there's an Earth-2 Fortress of Solitude that Lionel controls, after years of work it took he and Clark to silence Clark's "progenitor" Jor-El.
On Earth-1, Tess inherits a Kryptonian artifact willed to the "heir of Lionel Luthor", which is now Tess. (It's still better than being the heir of Slytherin.) The artifact is a shiny crystal called a Mirrorbox, capable of transporting Kryptonians (and possibly anyone though only the Clarks switched places) to the parallel Earth. Clark summons Tess to Cadmus about a break in that he and Oliver tracked, and once there, Tess' jig - the jig being "I've known about the clones of Lex Luthor and I've been hiding the surviving one, Alexander, and playing mommy to him - because I'm also a Lionel Luthor's daughter" - is up! Clark was especially unnerved by Alexander's bedroom and his wall of scratched in S symbols. That little bastard and his copyright infringements! (Actually, we don't know how old Alexander is now with his rapid-aging problem.) Clark totally loses it, and Tess is about to have an emotional breakdown because she's wanted Clark to trust her for so long and now she thinks she's blown it, until Clark opens the Mirrorbox and Things Get Worse.
Clark ends up in on Earth-2, where every thing is in black and white and everyone but Lionel and Tess are terrified of him. Clark explores his Earth-2 options, trying to find out who has the Mirrorbox so he can go back home, where there's color and no one automatically soils their pants in his presence. Lois is engaged to Oliver and they both hate him/Clark Luthor. Lionel leads Clark on to suspect Oliver has the Mirrorbox, so Clark does the only thing he can do: he kidnaps Lois and holds her ransom in exchange for the Mirrorbox. But Clark's real ulterior motive is to talk to Lois, to tell her about who he really is and of this wonderful, colorful other world where he and Lois are in love and they fight for Truth, Justice and the American Way together. Lois isn't buying Clark's story until he says the following in the most impassioned speech Tom Welling has ever delivered on Smallville:
"Where I'm from, Lois Lane, you and I, we're allies. You always have my back. How else would I know you're brave and loyal? And a force of nature. Look, you misspell words, simple words, at an alarmingly frequent basis! And you never admit when I'm right, even when I call you on it. And you can always tell when I'm lying. You can see right through me, straight to my soul, to my heart. My name is Clark Kent and I promise, Lois, I will never let this world happen to us. I can't live in a world where you don't love me."
Wow. A couple of Superman: The Movie references in that speech, especially the one major character point of Lois invented by Dick Donner and Tom Mankiewicz that will be part of the character forever: Lois Lane can't spell. Clark also has snappy banter to Lois when it's all over:
"Nothing says 'Sorry my doppelganger from a parallel Earth tried to kill you' like flowers." There's also a great winking joke by Lois about how many times in the series she's had to sign medical release forms.
Meanwhile, Clark Luthor ends up on Earth-1 and goes right looking for his sister-lover. (Buster Bluth has never been so jealous. And is it me or is Earth-2 Tess looking hotter?) Tess manages to swallow down Ultraman's tongue in surprise when he kisses her, and then swallow down her abject terror at Ultraman's potential to kill her and everyone in Metropolis long enough to bluff him. Tess calls Lois, who ignores her, so Tess uses Watchtower to cut off Lois' credit, track her via security cameras and call the cell phone of the hapless dude standing behind her in the coffee line to summon Lois to Watchtower. (Maybe everyone on The Team just needs signal watches.) Once at Watchtower, there's hardly time to explain what's going on before Ultraman explodes into Watchtower and starts beating up Smallville chicks.
On Earth-2, Clark goes to Watchtower to get the Mirrorbox from Oliver but falls right into Oliver's mousetrap, a Kryptonite beam. Oliver has one in every major city, and his business is buying up farmland in Smallville, evicting the farmers, and mining for meteor rocks. Lionel saves Clark from a Queen bullet, but only because he wants to kill Clark himself. Lionel, who in a bizarre lapse of his perceptive genius, still doesn't realize this Clark isn't the one he raised, took off his belt and gave his "son" a whoopin' because he's long feared Clark betraying him. ("What were you planning, to take the Mirrorbox and go to another world with your whore sister?") Oliver de-activates the K-beam so Clark can punch Lionel across the room, rather brutally too. I guess he was mad about the whippings. Assuring Oliver that in his world they save the world together, Clark opens the Mirrorbox and finds himself back in color, staring at the barrel of Tess' gun, and Oliver and Lois' K-arrows on Earth-1. Everything, and everyone, is back to where they were.
Or are they? Clark visits Tess at the mansion, apologizes to her for his "Luthor blood is poison line", and holds her hand in a touching scene of trust and reconciliation. Tess confesses the worst part of being Lionel's daughter is that she's actually hurt that "he threw me away". (Good thing she never heard Earth-2 Lionel tell her doppelganger that she isn't "special enough"). Clark and Tess both know Alexander Luthor is out there. But what they don't know is that so is Lionel Luthor! Now, in color! Lionel Luthor buying coffee and walking the streets of Earth-1 Metropolis! Is this the Earth-2 Lionel? Did he use the Mirrorbox? Is Clark Luthor dead?
All I know is the return of Julian John Glover at maximum diabolical evil as Lionel Luthor was a shot in the arm for Smallville. Even without the presence of Michael Rosenbaum, having an evil Luthor as the Enemy just feels right, and Earth-2 Lionel was even more dangerous and ruthless than the Lionel we knew, and he was plenty dangerous and ruthless. Plus Darkseid is still out there. And next week: The return of Slade Wilson, Deathstroke the Terminator, and a Justice League/Justice Society team up! If all that doesn't spell a Crisis on Smallville, I don't know what does.
(edited by John Orquiola on 4.12.10 2043) @BackoftheHead
Tom has a future as a villain in films and TV. He plays it so easily. I have to say I loved Lionel breaking the fourth wall at the end, just beautiful. Ultraman was awesome, but I was hoping for Owlman just to get away from the no Batman rule. I am just glad they didn't break up Lois and Clark which is going to be my great fear through out the rest of the series. It was a nice way to introduce to Earth-2, but some of the stuff they are doing this season should have been done years ago. Imagine an entire season of Earth-2 characters invading Earth-1. We have also have an Alexander Luthor. We are just a few steps from Crisis. As great as this episode was, the JLA vs. the Suicide Squad or least Deathstroke and the government looks awesome.
I was actually expecting Clark Kent vs. Clark Luthor in the wreckage of Watchtower as an nod to Superman III.
It pains me to say this, but with Lionel now galavanting around Earth-1 Metropolis, I'm starting to think Tess isn't much longer for this world. If Tess survives to the end of the season/series, it'll be a miracle. Although, how awesome would it be if she kills Lionel - meaning both of Lionel Luthor's children killed him in Earth-1?
I would pay Smallville's producers cash money to see Clark Luthor lead the Crime Syndicate against Clark Kent's Justice League.
(edited by John Orquiola on 4.12.10 1032) @BackoftheHead
John, I assume you do know there's another actor actually named Julian Glover?
Originally posted by The GoonA lot happened offscreen - I would have liked to see the battle between Clark Luthor and Tess/Ollie/Lois
Ditto. It looks like it was a really badass battle.
I'm really getting sick of this black & white bullshit. I didn't spend all this fucking money on HDTV to watch B&W and I'm not so stupid I can't tell flashbacks/dreams/alternate universes without it.
Other than that I enjoyed the hell out of it. I'm a sucker for mirror universes/what if...hell, I ended up watching an entire episode of Ugly Betty because it. You can always tell the actors have so much fun getting to play a totally different take on their characters.
Originally posted by MossJohn, I assume you do know there's another actor actually named Julian Glover?
No, I did not. Funny too since I recognize Julian Glover from Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, For Your Eyes Only, and Empire Strikes Back. No wonder John Glover never answers when I call him Julian. And neither of them answer when I call them Danny.
(edited by John Orquiola on 4.12.10 2046) @BackoftheHead
The final scene with Lionel looking into the camera and pretty much saying "you guys getting ready for the super-duper finale?" made me cackle.
I think Lionel just didn't care from which reality Clark came. He just wanted to whoop someone because he failed to raise his Clark bad-ass enough to the point where he'd rather kill Lionel himself than flee to another world.
Earth-2 Tess looked a bit hotter indeed, possibly because she didn't have to be all business like.
I think the thing she and Clark said, that Alexander would reveal himself on his terms must mean that yes, we should expect Michael Rosenbaum to pop up but we will not know for sure just yet. I think it'd be great to see him in the season finale, swoop in to sorta save the day and then have a stare down with Clark/Superman to end the show.
Well, I like the premise, and of course Tim Roth is Tim Roth, but I feel like the execution is a little shakey so far. The scripts come off as really mediocre to me. It helps that the other principle actors (besides Roth)