The W
Views: 133134029
Main | FAQ | Search: Y! / G | Calendar | Color chart | Log in for more!
21.5.18 1938
The W - Basketball - Rookie of the Year: Who's your pick?
This thread has 3 referrals leading to it
Register and log in to post!
Thread rated: 5.93
Pages: 1
(1176 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
Post (12 total)
Big Bad

Since: 4.1.02
From: Dorchester, Ontario

Since last post: 4 days
Last activity: 2 days
#1 Posted on | Instant Rating: 5.67
Carmelo or Lebron or Dar....oh wait, never mind that last one.

I don't want to hear any bullshit about a shared award, just your flat-out opinion on who the ROY should be.

In my mind, it's Carmelo by a hair. The fact that he led Denver to the playoffs in THAT conference puts him over the top.


Stretcher of limbs, stretcher of the truth

Promote this thread!

Since: 2.1.02
From: Seattle, WA

Since last post: 847 days
Last activity: 425 days
#2 Posted on | Instant Rating: 6.99
LeBron. I think Marc Stein made the point that if you switched them the Nugs still would've made the playoffs and the Cavs still wouldn't, and I agree. LeBron's 20-5-5 stat line is only the third time in NBA history a rookie has accomplished that, so I'm going with him. Props to 'Melo for a great season, though. He'd have easily beaten K-Mart, Mike Miller, and Amare the last three years. (Though YAO should've won last year, I thought.)

“To get ass, you’ve got to bring ass." -- Roy Jones Jr.

"Your input has been noted.
I hope you don't take it personally if I disregard it."
-- Guru Zim

"Speak English or face admin retribution." -- CRZ
Boudin rouge

Since: 2.1.02
From: Pittsburgh PA

Since last post: 3395 days
Last activity: 602 days
#3 Posted on | Instant Rating: 8.00
I gotta go with LeBron, for the same reason JJD made above. Additionally, the Nuggets had a completely revamped and improved roster before the season started. The point was made somewhere on (maybe in the most recent power rankings) that the Cavs took over half of a season to tailor the lineup to suit LeBron. Give him McInnis and crew the whole season and the Cavs cruise into the playoffs. Carmelo had Jon Barry, a vastly improved Nene, and a true PG in Andre Miller to get him the ball.

Also, as a dark horse, I think one has to look at Dwayne Wade from the Heat. He obviously won't win it, but in any other year, I think he has to be a lock, especially for leading that relatively moribund team to the playoffs (even if Lamar Odom and Rafer Alston had a great deal to do with that as well).

(edited by HitTheSnoozeButton on 14.4.04 2135)

"She's screaming like crazy...You have this myth you're sharing the birth experience. Unless you're passing a bowling ball, I don't think so. Unless you're circumcising yourself with a chainsaw, I don't think so. Unless you're opening an umbrella up your ass, I don't think so."
--Robin Williams on birth
Potato korv

Since: 27.2.03
From: Seattle, Washington

Since last post: 3451 days
Last activity: 54 days
#4 Posted on | Instant Rating: 4.77
Plus, LeBron had the Cavs (the CAVS!) in playoff contention late in the year, with a lesser supporting staff than 'Melo had. Combine that with the tremendous pressure and expectation set on him, and I think LeBron has to win.

"It's the four pillars of the male heterosexual psyche. We like naked women, stockings, lesbians, and Sean Connery best as James Bond because that is what being a [man] is." -Jack Davenport, Coupling

Since: 12.1.02
From: Fresno, CA

Since last post: 14 days
Last activity: 2 hours
#5 Posted on | Instant Rating: 6.23

Kirk Hinrich, PG, Bulls


(Not Bob Kohm)

In the context of baseball, the use of drugs hurts only the player. In the context of baseball, the use of alcohol hurts only the player. In the context of baseball, womanizing hurts whom? Maybe the wife of the player? In the context of baseball, felonies are crimes against society, not against baseball. In the context of baseball, gambling is the only crime against baseball.

Gambling, in the context of baseball, is a capital offense and Rose has richly earned-- hell, he agreed to-- his death sentence. Let him hang.

Bob Kohm, co-owner of ( , and a large market kind of guy.

Since: 2.1.02
From: Bronx, NY

Since last post: 3265 days
Last activity: 1525 days
#6 Posted on | Instant Rating: 5.86
Just give it to both Carmelo and LeBron. They both deserve it.

Co-Rookies of the Year. Not a bad thing.

(edited by Kawshen on 14.4.04 2232)

The Amazing Salami

Since: 23.5.02
From: Oklahoma

Since last post: 5094 days
Last activity: 5093 days
#7 Posted on | Instant Rating: 4.85
    Originally posted by Battlezone
    Plus, LeBron had the Cavs (the CAVS!) in playoff contention late in the year, with a lesser supporting staff than 'Melo had. Combine that with the tremendous pressure and expectation set on him, and I think LeBron has to win.

But Cleveland plays in the EAST....everyone is in playoff contention in the East. Well, except Chicago

Seriously, getting the Nuggets into the playoffs in the West is a very big deal. Even if the Cavs had made the playoffs in the East, I'd still go with Melo. Since they didn't....well, I definitely go with Melo.

Yes, the Cavs are sucky and always have been. Turning them least an accomplishment.

BUT Denver and Cleveland finished with identical records last season...both had just 17 wins. Denver finished with a winning record in the West. Cleveland finished with a losing record in the East. That makes the choice easy to me.

The Amazing Salami's Not-So-Random
W of the Arbitrary Segment of Time

Parts Unknown says: Never wear your best pants when you go to fight for freedom.

Since: 6.1.02
From: Pittsburgh, PA

Since last post: 3 days
Last activity: 1 day
#8 Posted on | Instant Rating: 5.71
    Originally posted by Whitebacon
    HOMER ALERT!!!!:

    Kirk Hinrich, PG, Bulls


Well that's probably more reasonable than my homer pick.

It should obviously be Udonis Haslem.

Lance's Response:

Summer sausage

Since: 2.1.02
From: Nashville

Since last post: 4486 days
Last activity: 2874 days
#9 Posted on | Instant Rating: 7.30
no one rookie has EVER had as much pressure on him as Lebron had this season. All eyes have been on him ALL season, and he still put up 20-5-5. With all due respect to Carmelo, (who had a GREAT year too), I think Lebron's the no-brainer.

SWEET 16!!!! Yeah, you read it vs. the UCONN Lakers

Since: 9.1.02
From: Virginia Beach Va

Since last post: 1888 days
Last activity: 88 days
#10 Posted on | Instant Rating: 4.32
Im going with Carmelo, simply because his team is in the playoffs. And Im not a LeBron hater, even though I think some of you think so.

"I want what you want. Yes, that's it Mr. Anderson. Look past the flesh, look through the soft gelatin of these dull cow eyes and see your enemy."

Since: 12.2.02
From: Cleveland, Ohio

Since last post: 41 days
Last activity: 3 hours
#11 Posted on | Instant Rating: 6.39
LeBron, pretty much for the reasons that JJD listed. He was awesome this year, really turned it up a notch when he had to. Correct me if I'm worng, but Melo was at one position all year. LeBron actually started out at point guard, straight from high school! When the Cavs finally got McInnis, LeBron was able to move to shooting guard and really blossom. That's some impressive versatility there. Trust me, the Cavs do not have nearly the supporting cast that the Nuggets had this year. Z and Boozer are going to become that, but they're still young(-ish for Z).

Cavaliers: 35-47. Here's to next year!
Indians: 3-7. Look out below!
Browns: 0-0

The last WOTD of 2003! FINALLY!
Lap cheong

Since: 10.8.02
From: Queen's University, Canada

Since last post: 4684 days
Last activity: 4593 days
#12 Posted on | Instant Rating: 5.10
Again, echoing JJD, I think it has to go to LeBron based on the criteria for the award. The rookie of the year is the rookie who has the best individual season, not the rookie who is most valuable to his team, correct? Those are two totally different questions. Rookie MVP is Carmelo, ROY is LeBron.

Don't you hate pants?
Thread rated: 5.93
Pages: 1
Thread ahead: Suns to be sold to group with Kerr, Barkley, Elliott
Next thread: NBA Playoff Bracket
Previous thread: Stephen A Scott Scares The Shit Out Of Bob Ley
(1176 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
The Miz said on Twitter that he was amazed he wasn't asked to be in it. Claimed he's the only guy to bring C-Town a championship lately...heh heh. :-)
- The Thrill, A bad attempt by Ohio's finest (2010)
Related threads: Wild Wednesday - Im officially through with the NBA... - SLAM DUNK CONTEST - *DUD - More...
The W - Basketball - Rookie of the Year: Who's your pick?Register and log in to post!

The W™ message board

©2001-2018 Brothers Zim

This old hunk of junk rendered your page in 0.272 seconds.