The W
Views: 100259582
Main | FAQ | Search: Y! / G | Calendar | Color chart | Log in for more!
31.10.14 0204
The W - Pro Wrestling - RAW Mid-Year Report Card
This thread has 7 referrals leading to it
Register and log in to post!
Thread rated: 3.50
Pages: 1 2 Next
(6419 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
User
Post (28 total)
chill
Landjager








Since: 18.5.02

Since last post: 2695 days
Last activity: 2695 days
#1 Posted on | Instant Rating: 1.88
Time to give out the grades!!


A-TRAIN n/a

AL SNOW n/a

BATISTA B+
He's coming into his own. He's being put over as a huge monster now. A year from now, he'll be an awesome force in the business.

CHRIS BENOIT A
It's all been said before.

CHRIS JERICHO B+
He's got nothing to do right now. I guess they were relying heavily on more Jericho/Christian stuff through the summer, before Christian got injured.

CHRIS NOWINSKI n/a

CHRISTIAN A-
Great job this year overall.

CHUCK PALUMBO n/a

EDGE C
I'm not impressed, but he's over for now.

ERIC BISCHOFF C+

EUGENE A
Dinsmore has really run with the ball, since being given this gimmick. He's over (big time!), his matches are entertaining, he is a success so far.

GAIL KIM B
Without any more injuries and continuing her current momentum, she'll be closer to an A in 6 months. She and Molly lead the ladies in ring work right now.

GARRISON CADE B-
His ring work is solid, but he's going to have a hard time getting over if he's not given time on RAW and time to speak.

IVORY n/a

JAZZ B
Her injuries keep her down too much, but total charisma in the ring. She sells her angry-black-woman character like a pro. One of the most underrated performers on the roster when she's healthy.

JERRY LAWLER D
The goofiness has run its course..about 6 years ago. Lawler has a lot of experience, why can't he be used as a proper colour commentator, explaining the MOVES in each match? He was much better during his first run in the old WWF, when he and Bret feuded.

JIM ROSS C
Call a match by showing you know what the moves are called, and I'll be impressed. It's totally believable, based on viewing RAW each week, for someone to think that JR has no clue what 70% of the moves are called - especially when Jericho uses the Lionsault but JR instead just calls it a "splash" or "whatta move off the ropes!" Enough.

JOHNNY NITRO C-
Shows promise. He'll need to prove he belongs in the ring whenever he returns.

JON HEIDENREICH F
Sloppy.

JONATHAN COACHMAN A
One of the most entertaining characters on RAW. Great turnaround for Coach, as he was quite hated when he was a neutral/face commentator on HEAT. The cockiness is priceless. Do something with "The Players Club" that's written on his entrance video!

KANE A-
Despite being thrown some curveball angles, he's persevered enough to claim a spot near the top. Good "comeback" if you can call it that.

LITA D
Awful ring worker. I can't suspend my disbelief when I watch her fight - I see right through her wrestling. Looks way too fake, but I'm sure she's protecting herself...possibly too much.

MATT HARDY C
On Smackdown he was actually interesting.

MOLLY HOLLY B+

NIDIA D
Bleh. I'm still waiting to see something. Anything.

RANDY ORTON A-
He's had a lot of help in getting and staying where he is, but he's doing enough on his own to deserve his spot.

RHYNO C+
He's impressed me a lot in his few matches on RAW, despite not being given a solid face or heel status. He could be very useful.

RIC FLAIR A-
His wrestling is predictable, however he's still good enough to justify being in the ring. His interviews and leadership role on camera for Evolution has raised the group's credibility to no ends. The man still has it.

ROB CONWAY B
Good wrestling. Questionable whether or not he's turning a bad gimmick into gold like Dinsmore is.

ROSEY D
Decent wrestling. Going nowhere. He could be a vicious heel. What a waste of time this gimmick was.

SHAWN MICHAELS A+
I despise HBK, but he's been a boon to RAW. Worth every cent they're paying him.

SHELTON BENJAMIN B
Poor mic work is the only thing holding him back from being a believable top tier wrestler at the moment.

STACY KEIBLER C
Tits and ass. I get it. But do we have to watch her wrestle??

STEVEN RICHARDS C-

SYLVAIN GRENIER B-
He's improved. That's the good news. And I am starting to really like his promos. He's a lot better now than during La Rez's first run.

TAJIRI A-
Solid work. Great facial expressions to sell his backstage promo work.

TEST n/a

THE HURRICANE F
Not his own fault. His character is also very stale. There's no profitable future in it, so trash the superhero crap or move him to Smackdown where he can fit in (in terms of his character). What a shameful waste of talent. I'd love to see Helms as a bastard heel.

THE ROCK A
Sure, we all know he's not around. If we can move past that, is it worth bringing him back for 3 appearances per year? Hell yes. Again, I'm as big a Rock fan as I like HBK, but the man is a top grade entertainer.

TRISH STRATUS B-
Her heel turn stumbled out of the blocks. I'm not sold on her character right now, but her matches have been pretty good.

TRIPLE H A+
The total MVP of RAW. He single-handedly got Benoit over, much the same way that retiring Cactus Jack brought HHH into the main event full-time. He's made all the right moves for business this year. Kudos. And he sells his character very well... even if several others could do the same if they had the same TV time.

TYSON TOMKO n/a
I haven't seen enough yet.

VAL VENIS n/a
Huh? Wha? The reprisal of this gimmick confused me. Wasn't it doomed to fail?

VICTORIA B
Decent. Her character is pretty non-existant now as a face.

WILLIAM REGAL B+
Good work so far.
Promote this thread!
ekedolphin
Scrapple








Since: 12.1.02
From: Indianapolis, IN; now residing in Suffolk, VA

Since last post: 134 days
Last activity: 7 days
#2 Posted on | Instant Rating: 4.52
I don't understand the C+ grade for Eric Bischoff. Personally, I think he adds a lot to RAW.



“Finally, finally, my God finally, Chris Benoit is the Heavyweight Champion of this world!”
--Jim Ross, WrestleMania XX

Two-Time Wiener of the Day (5/27/02; 7/3/02)

Certified RFMC Member-- Ask To See My Credentials!

Packman V2
Bratwurst








Since: 16.3.04
From: Albuquerque, NM

Since last post: 56 days
Last activity: 5 hours
AIM:  
Y!:
#3 Posted on | Instant Rating: 0.71
Good job....don't have any major complaints about any of the grades..and it would definitely be nice if they gave Hurricane and Rosey a fresh start, and scrap both gimmicks. Repackage Rosey with Rhyno, and let them work in the tag division....could be a good tandem.

Overall I like the roster better than last year, but just wish Tajiri and Rhyno would get a fairer shake. These guys were the big reasons I watched ECW's TNN show. Well, them and the Impact Players.





GO PACK GO!!!
chill
Landjager








Since: 18.5.02

Since last post: 2695 days
Last activity: 2695 days
#4 Posted on | Instant Rating: 1.88
The grade for Bischoff would be higher if they hadn't taken away his edge. I don't see much reason for him being on the show the way his character is treated now. Is he absolutely necessary right now? No. I'd love to see the E give him more edge with a few allies who do his dirty work. Every a**hole boss has a few workers who he/she sides with constantly.

Feel free to give your own grades. Comments aren't necessary, but you may be questioned on certain grades by others.
A Fan
Liverwurst








Since: 3.1.02

Since last post: 3565 days
Last activity: 3565 days
#5 Posted on | Instant Rating: 2.68
HHH, an A+, I don't think so. I will say the guy has stepped it up lately, but I was there live during the Royal Rumble and it sucked. I will give him and Shawn at least a B, because of that much and the fact that last night's Hell in a Cell was just an average Cell match. I am not sure who I would grade higher, but I don't believe Orton has earned his spot. Orton is a C. Edge has been great of late with his tag matches with Benoit. He just needs some more singles competition and get rid of some of that ring rust and he will be fine.
bigredmachine29
Linguica








Since: 12.5.04
From: new jersey

Since last post: 3350 days
Last activity: 2810 days
AIM:  
#6 Posted on | Instant Rating: 6.00
I think Trips deserves an A+. You might not like the rumors about his politics backstage, but if you watched RAW last night, you know he deserves an A+ rating. The guy can single handedly make a RAW interesting.
asteroidboy
Andouille








Since: 22.1.02
From: Texas

Since last post: 1437 days
Last activity: 345 days
#7 Posted on | Instant Rating: 4.95
Yeah, I liked how he got Benoit over on RAW, calling him Jericho's "little buddy." Asshole.

But he DID tap out to him at Wrestlemania. I'd give Trip a definite A.



-- Asteroid Boy


Wiener of the day: 23.7.02, 3.12.03

"In addition, my tickets weren’t really what you’d expect from the webmaster of the internet’s largest independent pro-wrestling website." - Widro

"My brother saw the Undertaker walking through an airport." - Rex
"Was he no-selling?" - Me


Quezzy
Knackwurst








Since: 6.1.02
From: Pittsburgh, PA

Since last post: 2 days
Last activity: 1 day
#8 Posted on | Instant Rating: 5.20
I agree with eke on Bischoff, he's doing really well, if it wasn't for Heyman being awesome then Bischoff would've been the best GM in years.

I don't disagree with the Triple H grade either, I didn't think his match at Rumble was that bad, and even if it was he's put on good ppvs matches since then. Both three way matches were great, haven't seen the hell in the cell yet, but i've heard it wasn't too bad. He's stepped it up on the mic I think too. Last night he was great in both the HBK feud and the upcoming Eugene match.

Stevie is great and even though we rarely see him on Raw he's very entertaining whenver he's around, I'd give him a B. ANd Hurricane, yeah, the gimmick has run it's course, but that's not his fault, he can't control what they give him to do so I don't think you can give him a bad grade because someone else gave him a bad gimmick. I'd give him a C. And I have a hard time giving Garrison Cade a B unless your definition of "solid" is bland. And an A for Coachman? He has no talent at anything wrestling related. Any screen time he gets is a complete waste.



Lance's Response:

THAT IS AWESOME!
A Fan
Liverwurst








Since: 3.1.02

Since last post: 3565 days
Last activity: 3565 days
#9 Posted on | Instant Rating: 2.68
I would give him a B+, but if you had to sit through that match after paying $75.00. I think you would see my reasoning. Thank God, the Rumble match is my pick for match of the year or I'd be pissed.
Quezzy
Knackwurst








Since: 6.1.02
From: Pittsburgh, PA

Since last post: 2 days
Last activity: 1 day
#10 Posted on | Instant Rating: 5.20
    Originally posted by A Fan
    I would give him a B+, but if you had to sit through that match after paying $75.00. I think you would see my reasoning. Thank God, the Rumble match is my pick for match of the year or I'd be pissed.


This is true, i see all the ppvs for free, so i rarely feel gipped unless it was just a complete waste of my time.



Lance's Response:

THAT IS AWESOME!
lmo911
Italian








Since: 2.1.02
From: A ways past Parts Unknown and to the left of Dudleyville

Since last post: 3542 days
Last activity: 1291 days
AIM:  
#11 Posted on | Instant Rating: 5.65
Thoughts?

-Giving Gail Kim a B maybe a little too much. Her offense has been much better, but I still think she's lacking. I'd give her a solid C

-Hurricane deserves more than an F (Especially with blocks of wood like Cade getting B's) Entertaining in the ring, but saddled with his gimmick. I want a return of Sugar Shane on Smackdown! Would help both of them! C

-Val I'd give a C-, probably the most under utilized worker in the company and unlike the Hurricane he can't even get on RAW with his crappy gimmick.

-Cade a B? I just don't see it. He doesn't do anything for me. At least Jendrak could look interesting (not as Lex Luger-lite though.)

-Stevie deserves a B, he's always entertaining even when he's doing nothing. Hell! Send Stevie, Val and Helms over to Smackdown and let them do something! I don't think they could actually make things worse over there!

And Batista get his "+" docked for his goofy dancing!





I knew it was too good to last...
Mr.Slipknot5
Weisswurst








Since: 19.6.04
From: Illinois

Since last post: 3784 days
Last activity: 3784 days
#12 Posted on | Instant Rating: 0.00
How can The Rock get an A?All he does is go out to be with a freind or make a freind,say a few crack jokes to a heel,lose at a paperview and leave for3 months and to a movie.That cycle continue.Solid d.Disapointing the way there sending him.



POOP
Mild Mannered Madman
Toulouse








Since: 1.3.02
From: Westminster, CA

Since last post: 477 days
Last activity: 195 days
#13 Posted on | Instant Rating: 5.68
    Originally posted by chill
    Time to give out the grades!!<

    AL SNOW n/a


F. For a guy who could be SO good as a color commentator, his naming everybody "Babaganoush" is disrespectful, tired, and annoying.





There is a theory which states that if ever anyone discovers exactly what the Universe is for and why it is here, it will instantly disappear and be replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable. There is another theory which states that this has already happened.
- The Restaurant at the End of the Universe
Mr.Slipknot5
Weisswurst








Since: 19.6.04
From: Illinois

Since last post: 3784 days
Last activity: 3784 days
#14 Posted on | Instant Rating: 0.00
    Originally posted by Mild Mannered Madman
      Originally posted by chill
      Time to give out the grades!!<

      AL SNOW n/a


    F. For a guy who could be SO good as a color commentator, his naming everybody "Babaganoush" is disrespectful, tired, and annoying.




Now come on,Al Snow gets a solid C.He atleast does heat and thats one of the only reasons I watch heat.I just want him to be a wrestler again.Raw doesnt try this kind of stuff enough.



POOP
AlboDude
Tocino








Since: 8.10.03
From: Georgia

Since last post: 2993 days
Last activity: 2812 days
#15 Posted on | Instant Rating: 7.00
My grades:

Al Snow - C
could be used much more than he is now

A-Train - D
Why is this waste of space still on the roster?

Batista - B
Good to see him finally getting over, and as said before, he's coming into his own very nicely

Chris Benoit - B
The only reason I'm not giving him an A is because he still looks a little shaky on the mic. Granted, he's come a long way since his WCW days, but there is still room for improvement

Chris Jericho - A
Face turn has really helped since he was as stale as 3 year old crutons as a heel

Chris Nowinski - n/a
too bad he's suffered what was possibly a career ending concussion, I always found his stuff to be entertaining

Christian - A
very much improved on the mic, and seems to have found his place as a cocky prick heel

Chuck Palumbo - D-
Time to bring back his Lex Luger imitator gimmick. I always found that to be funny, especially with that little exercise thing he brought to the ring

Edge - C-
Seems to be floudering just a bit. Enough with the serious attitude and bring back the fun-loving Edge who played pranks on heels

Eric Bischoff - B
Done well for what he has to work with

Eugene - A+
The most over wrestler on the roster no doubt. Has taken a very questionable gimmick and turned it to gold.

Gail Kim - D
Still looks sloppy in the ring, although not as bad as when she first debuted

Garrison Cade - F
No mic skills to speak of, Green as grass, and has the charisma of a fingernail

Ivory - n/a
She's still with the company?

Jazz - B
Her angry black woman schtick is entertaining. Hopefully she'll be put into some more angles and feuds now that Rodney Mack is back

Jerry Lawler - B
Still entertaining, although not as much as he used to be. Would earn an A if not for yelling puppies so damn much

Jim Ross - C-
tired cliches and going through the motions almost sounds like JR doesnt even care anymore

Johnny Nitro - B-
Definately some potential there. Kind of reminds me of a young Scott Levy

John Heidenreich - n/a
Havent seen enough of him to give him a grade. But I'll take everyones word for it that he's really really bad

Johnathan Coachman - A
Has been gold since his heel turn

Kane - A+
Awesome promo skills and decent in-ring ability for a man of his size. I think good run with the title should definately be in his future

Lita - C
Good character, but lousy ring worker. Would be higher if she improved her skills a little

Matt Hardy - C+
At least he's a face now

Molly Holly - B+
Too bad all her hair is gone. Hopefully it will grow back soon

Nidia - n/a
havent seen enough of her

Randy Orton - B
He's coming into his own despite being forcefed down everyones throats. 6 months ago, I would have given him a D, but has slowly but surely gotten over

Rhyno - D
Glorfied jobber

Ric Flair - C-
Playing second fiddle to the likes of Triple H and Randy Orton is no place for a natural born leader like the Nature Boy

Rob Conway - B+
Has done well for having a bad gimmick. Time will tell if he's able to reach the next level

Rodney Mack - B-
Have always been a mark for the Thuggin N Buggin. If only Teddy Long was still on Raw

Rosey - F
Bring back 3 Minute Warning

Scott Steiner - B-
If he was the worker he was 10 years ago, he'd be an A+ no problem. He has it on the mic (gotta love some of those off the wall promos) but his size has taken its toll on his ring work. Hopefully he'll turn up soon

Shawn Michaels - B
Would be an A, but his neverending fued with Triple H has dragged him down

Shelton Benjamin - B-
Has that "it" quality, but needs to work on promo skills

Stacy Kiebler - F
Can't act, can't wrestle. Simply awful.

Steven Richards - D
see Rhyno

Sylvan Grenier - B-
Has improved a great deal and seems to gel better with Conway than Dupree

Tajiri - C
Lack of promo skills hurts his standing

Test - B
I know ya'll are going to hate me for this, but I've always been entertained by the guy, in a Plan 9 from Outer Space sort of way. He can't act his way out of a paper bag but its just so damn unintentionally funny that every time I watch him try to deliver his lines, I crack my ass up laughing. His in ring work is much the same way

The Hurricane - D
Hasnt had much to do

The Rock - n/a
Hasnt made enough appearances to justify a grade

Trish Stratus - B+
Has made good of her heel turn

Triple H - C-
Always has been my bathroom break, totally stale. Although his match with Eugene looks to be interesting

Tyson Tomko - C
nothing great, but nothing horrible either

Val Venis - D-
Looks to be on his way out of the company soon

Victoria - B
She needs to go back to being psycho. You don't nessesarily have to turn her heel, but just let her regress back into her old character

William Regal - A
Facial expression and acting has always been some of the best in the business




Mr.Slipknot5
Weisswurst








Since: 19.6.04
From: Illinois

Since last post: 3784 days
Last activity: 3784 days
#16 Posted on | Instant Rating: 0.00
How can Test get that high of a grade!He was a bad wrestler and then he got injured and he hasnt been back since then!He gets a D-.The whole thing with the Stacy and Scott Steiner thing drug him down this year.Come back year Test and just wrestle.



POOP
AlboDude
Tocino








Since: 8.10.03
From: Georgia

Since last post: 2993 days
Last activity: 2812 days
#17 Posted on | Instant Rating: 7.00
If you bothered to read my post then you would have understood why I gave Test such a high mark. Simply put, he makes me laugh, and while the Steiner/Stacy angle seemed to never end, I still was entertained by his promo skills (or lack thereof) because they were just so damn unintentionally funny that you couldn't help but laugh at them. Hate on Test all you want, but the guy is gold when it comes to unintentional comedic value
Spaceman Spiff
Knackwurst








Since: 2.1.02
From: Philly Suburbs

Since last post: 16 days
Last activity: 3 hours
AIM:  
#18 Posted on | Instant Rating: 4.05
    Originally posted by AlboDude
    A-Train - D
    Why is this waste of space still on the roster?

A-Train is nowhere near as bad as everyone claims. He's a solid wreslter, and would make a good midcard heel. If anything, give him a n/a since he's had a grand total of 1 match on Raw, but don't insinuate that Tomko or Steiner or Test or Lita are better than him.



Mr.Slipknot5
Weisswurst








Since: 19.6.04
From: Illinois

Since last post: 3784 days
Last activity: 3784 days
#19 Posted on | Instant Rating: 0.00
    Originally posted by AlboDude
    If you bothered to read my post then you would have understood why I gave Test such a high mark. Simply put, he makes me laugh, and while the Steiner/Stacy angle seemed to never end, I still was entertained by his promo skills (or lack thereof) because they were just so damn unintentionally funny that you couldn't help but laugh at them. Hate on Test all you want, but the guy is gold when it comes to unintentional comedic value


When Test made crack jokes it made me laugh at how BAD HE IS!I still give a solid D-.



POOP
Dutchie
Boerewors
Moderator








Since: 29.1.02
From: PA

Since last post: 8 days
Last activity: 2 hours
#20 Posted on | Instant Rating: 7.34
    Originally posted by Mr.Slipknot5
    When Test made crack jokes it made me laugh at how BAD HE IS!I still give a solid D-.


    Originally posted by The W registration page

    Please note that The W™ message board is a commercial service that is intended for use by adults. Occasionally, someone under 18 years old is able to communicate in a mature, intelligent manner - these people are welcome here. However, due to COPPA and associated reporting responsibilities that would be placed on this site, no one under the age of 16 may register for an account. If at any time it is determined that an account holder is under the age of 16, the account will be terminated.


I'm not disagreeing with you on Test. I'm just following the rules.



093093-012103
"Light beer? What's next, non-addictive painkillers?"

Our puppy (geocities.com) awwwww
Pages: 1 2 Next
Thread rated: 3.50
Pages: 1 2 Next
Thread ahead: Serious ways to improve Kenzo Suzuki
Next thread: TNA Impact rating
Previous thread: The Great Thomas SmackDown! Report (6/17/04)
(6419 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
It's funny, recently Danielson had done interviews saying that he's been able to learn to live with the shoulder pain. This might lead you to believe he may take some time off.
- MisterHenderson, ROH 12/23 (2006)
Related threads: Raw 6-14-04 - Lita is pregnant - RAW WORKRATE Report 6/7/04 - More...
The W - Pro Wrestling - RAW Mid-Year Report CardRegister and log in to post!

The W™ message board

ZimBoard
©2001-2014 Brothers Zim

This old hunk of junk rendered your page in 0.407 seconds.