Not that I normally touch that pop-up fest of a site with a ten foot pole, but looking at that one recap, you're definitely not alone there. (IMO) The gimmick only takes away from what was otherwise a competent review of the actual program.
Scouring the PWTorch message boards, Dusty is one of the more well-liked Torch contributors. He's no James Caldwell, who was ripped by Meltzer (and readers) for his review of the Bret Hart DVD (which probably is a whole 'nother thread).
Actually Scott did it because a) TheSmarks.com is having a million server problems, and b) People don't like to go to 411wrestling to read his recaps...or they can't access it from work or whatever, and it'll stop the "WHERE IS YOUR RECAP?