Originally posted by jfkfcSo if a writer thinks that no one on THIS LIST is HOF-worthy, then that automatically means that they should think that no one is HOF-worthy on THIS OTHER LIST?? The mere presence of Greg Maddux on THIS OTHER LIST should convince you otherwise....unless you're going with "If Piazza and Biggio don't get elected, then NO ONE should get elected." Then, while you might be completely silly, you'd at least be consistent.
I guess you could include Greg Maddux (and not Roger Clemens, who has similar career stats) because you assume that Maddux didn't use steroids. I hate getting into that game; I'm sure no one thought Andy Pettitte would have used PEDs, until it turned out that he did.
Yeah i seem to remember almost every high power offense is useless against Shilling and Johnson. Look at the cards during the playoffs last year. Morris pitched some gems... but we could do absolutely nothing against Shilling.