Originally posted by Mike Fitzpatrick, Associated PressLooking to shuffle their roster after an embarrassing collapse this season, the New York Mets found a new catcher and right fielder Friday.
The price: prized outfield prospect Lastings Milledge.
After holding onto Milledge through years of trade speculation, the Mets finally dealt him to the Washington Nationals for catcher Brian Schneider and outfielder Ryan Church.
"I thought we needed to change it up a little," New York general manager Omar Minaya said. "Names like Schneider and Church are not known names, but they give us balance."
"We're getting a guy who has a chance to be an impact bat in our lineup for years to come," Washington manager Manny Acta said.
What's amazing about the Mets historically is that the GM may change, but the horrible trades just keep on coming. How bad do I rate this one among the Mets worst? While history, of course, will be the ultimate judge, my own personal projection is that this one isn't as bad as Scott Kazmir for the wrong Zambrano, and (hopefully) not as bad as Jeff Kent for Carlos Baerga and Alvaro Espinoza. Amos Otis for Joy Foy looks to be a pretty close comp, though Ryan Church should have significantly more value in 2008 than Foy had in 1970. In fact, Church may have as good a 2008 season as Milledge will have, which would still make this a horrible trade for the Mets, as Milledge (who turns 23 next April) projects to improve significantly, while Church (who will be 30 before the next World Series begins) will begin to decline.
Again, I must repeat that history will be the ultimate judge; after all, this is baseball, where anything can happen. But based upon what we know today, this transaction has a good chance of entering the Top Ten Worst Trades Ever Made By The New York Mets. And that's saying something.
For those interested, the full article may be found here (sports.yahoo.com)
Didn't they also turn down a Manny trade for Milledge? I'm not a huge Manny fan but I would certainly take him over Ryan Church.
It's bad enough that the trade is lopsided but the lack of Lastings Milledge also means one less chip to get Santana or Haren. I know they still have Carlos Gomez but obviously you'd rather keep one of them when a trade for a pitcher now means they probably will both be gone.
Really I get the feeling that they aren't going to get a pitcher now, which means a F- for this offseason.
Keep in mind the number of times he's fallen off the wagon. I view it as a combination of investment protection on the Reds' part and Hamilton's desire to not fall into that same trap again like he has so many times in the past.