In fact, Big Bad pointed out the lack of "love" for Bailey, and I noted that no one picked Coghlan. Turns out, they both won the awards yesterday. As a Marlins fan, I'm happy for Coghlan....he really helped keep the team in the playoff race down the stretch, and at the time he got called up, we were desperate for an OF that could hit. If he faltered, they didn't seem to have a backup plan.
Was it good or bad for the game? Depends on who you are, and where you stand in the game: 1. It's great for teams that are actually in contention for a playoff run. And take this scenario into consideration.