I downloaded this from Amazon a week or so ago and forgot to mention it.
That pretty much sums up how I felt about the show. I watched it all, thought he was trying too hard to be a cross between Horatio and the leading guy from the other CSI show (not in terms of knowledge, but in terms of mannerisms)
It was eh. I did not add it to my TiVo. I'll watch it if its on, I suppose.
My opinion might be slightly colored by the fact that I didn't have to pay to see this, but I liked it. I was worried going in because of reviews I had read, and that Carell might get a little too "over the top", but I was pleasantly surprised....