Although I can't say I'm a fan of Avenged Sevenfold's last two albums, The Rev's drumming was always excellent and his work on the band's first couple of albums is immaculate. 28 is just way too early to go.
I don't know what exactly you like. But you seem to have an eclectic taste like me. The only two albums on that list I own are the BEP and Neptunes albums. Between those two, i'd take the BEP album over the Neptunes album, personally.