Originally posted by Dave MeltzerShawn Michaels suffered a torn meniscus in the three-way match tonight in Chicago and needs surgery. It is not a definite at this point that he won't work tomorrow if he is voted in (and if he isn't, he theoretically should work the tag match), but at this point the odds are against him working.
It was a pretty bad sign when he couldn't even stand for the closing shot.
I'd guess if HBK wins and can't go, they'd announce him and the injury and have someone do double duty in the World title match and the Tag Team title match. But that's just a guess off the top of my head.
There's no pre-PPV Heat type show on the PPV schedule; they could let people know on the website or the pre-PPV preview show if they ruled HBK out, but I don't expect they will.
I do feel a little pity for WWE, who went out of their way to start voting as late as possible specifically to AVOID this sort of problem...what a bad situation to be in. Even if WWE provides x-rays to each fan who voted, it'll still make the whole thing look like a sham to the average viewer.
This really doesn't need to mess with things much. I had a feeling Benoit would win the vote even before Michaels got hurt since Edge is playing a heel and Hunter/Michaels has been done to death. That would leave Michaels/Edge against the Frenchies, where Michaels can get hurt from the get-go and they can do a Bret/Owen split between Michaels and Edge to cement the heel turn...which is what I think they were going for here anyway.
All you have to do is air a little skit during the PPV saying Evolution took out HBK and failed to take out the other guys so as to wrest power back from the voters, whom Triple H has consistently mocked.
Give Christian to Jericho and put Benjamin or Rhyno in with Benoit against La Resistance.
"To be the man, you gotta beat demands." -- The Lovely Mrs. Tracker
Sucks for HBK. Though he's certainly had a great run the last couple of years, if this is truly it for him.
You could always have Edge injure HBK (either on-screen or implied) at the show; give Benoit the title shot, and then have the "Edge joins Evolution" storyline I mentioned in the predictions thread yesterday....
Originally posted by The Vile1Does a torn meniscus truly mean the end for Shawn Michaels?
There are many factors to consider when deciding how to treat your torn meniscus, including the extent and location of the tear, your pain level, your age and activity level, your doctor's preference, and when the injury occurred. Your treatment choices are:
* Wait to see if it heals on its own, wearing a temporary knee brace and possibly starting physical rehabilitation. * Surgical repair, to sew the tear together. * Partial meniscectomy, surgery to remove the torn section. * Total meniscectomy, surgery to remove all of the meniscus. This is generally avoided, because this option increases the risk for osteoarthritis in the knee.
The location (zone) of the tear is one of the most important factors in healing.
Tears at the outer edge of the meniscus (red zone) tend to heal well because there is good blood supply. Minor tears may heal on their own with a brace and a period of rest. If they do not heal or repair is deemed necessary, the tear can be sewn together using dissolvable stitches. This is successful 90% to 95% of the time in this area.
The inner two-thirds (white zone) of the meniscus does not have a good blood supply and therefore does not heal well either on its own or after repair. If torn pieces float into the joint space, which may result in a "locked" knee or cause other symptoms, the torn portion is removed (partial meniscectomy) and the edges of the remaining meniscus are shaved to make the meniscus smooth.
When the tear extends from the red zone into the white zone, there may be adequate blood supply for healing. Studies of repairs of these kind of tears show varying results.
"To be the man, you gotta beat demands." -- The Lovely Mrs. Tracker
I vaguely remember Mick Foley saying in Have A Nice Day that he worked through a torn meniscus for several months in 1999 (from like the middle of February until the end of May) so this doesn't automatically mean the end of HBK's career.
Not a doctor, hanen't played one on TV... (But am an athletic klutz, & am certain I've paid for at least one of my orthopaedist's Mercedes.)
"Torn meniscus" is torn cartilage. Generally not a huge deal -- you get it "scoped" & get on with your life. (Although we (I) haven't actually heard what Charlie's damage was, given the 4 weeks anticipated return, it's very likely that's what his damage was.)
Matt's WebMd information is totally correct, although sounds more ominous than it actually is.
It absolutely does depend on the degree of damage. However, this is not the kind of thing that's career-ending for a pro wrestler. And Shawn's already playing with damage much worse than this.
Its one of those things that can look/seem/feel really bad. (Or, depending on the detalis of what or where, you can hardly even notice you have it. That's just luck.) Its very possible for the torn bit to lodge in the joint in any of various ways to "lock" the knee, or to keep it from straightening/flexing/whatever. And it can really hurt like hell. Sometimes the orthopaedist or trainer can manipulate the knee to temporarily dislodge the torn bit. (Or not.)
But scoping cartilage is bread & butter for orthopaedists. Unless there's something really extraordinarily weird about this particular damage, it's not a huge deal. He'll get it scoped & be back in 1-2 months.
(Just for comparison's sake, this isn't 10% of Matt Hardy's recent knee mess, where he was "working through" before having entire ligaments replaced. That's *much* worse.)
Thing is, Michaels could barely stand on Raw, and Meltz seems under the impression that the decision has already been made that surgery is necessary. Not career-ending, maybe, but it is a big deal. I really can't see him working a big match tonight.
Once upon a time in China, some believe, around the year one double-ought three, head priest of the White Lotus Clan, Pai Mei was walking down the road, contemplating whatever it is that a man of Pai Mei's infinite power contemplates - which is another way of saying "who knows" - when a Shaolin monk appeared, traveling in the opposite direction. As the monk and the priest crossed paths, Pai Mei, in a practically unfathomable display of generosity, gave the monk the slightest of nods. The nod was not returned. Now was it the intention of the Shaolin monk to insult Pai Mei or did he just fail to see the generous social gesture? The motives of the monk remain unknown. What is known, are the consequences. The next morning Pai Mei appeared at the Shaolin Temple and demanded of the Temple's head abbot that he offer Pai Mei his neck to repay the insult. The Abbot at first tried to console Pai Mei, only to find Pai Mei was inconsolable. So began the massacre of the Shaolin Temple and all 60 of the monks inside at the fists of the White Lotus. And so began the legend of Pai Mei's five point palm exploding heart technique.
I'm betting he never quite recovered from the ACL he tore before Wrestlemania.
There is a theory which states that if ever anyone discovers exactly what the Universe is for and why it is here, it will instantly disappear and be replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable. There is another theory which states that this has already happened. - The Restaurant at the End of the Universe
Originally posted by oldschoolheroThing is, Michaels could barely stand on Raw, and Meltz seems under the impression that the decision has already been made that surgery is necessary. Not career-ending, maybe, but it is a big deal. I really can't see him working a big match tonight.
Oh, absolutely -- "big deal" in terms of working tonight -- no doubt, no disagreement. I was referring specifically to "big deal" in terms of longer term & career. Sorry if I didn't make that clear.
MMM: That's a good point. It is much easier to get a cartilage tear if you've already loosened up the joint with ligament damage.
Thread ahead: Raw 10-18-04 Next thread: I enjoy starting threads about PPVs before the PPV before them has even happened...I'm a dork Previous thread: Taboo Tuesday Spoiler: La Resistance vs. Edge/Michaels/Benoit
Wait, I remember this plot from the old Super Friends cartoon. They thought Superman was dead, but instead he was in this weird pose that served to slow down his heart rate to a crawl so the kryptonite wouldn't affect him as strongly.