I was listening to the radio on the drive home, and former NFLer Harry Sydney was saying that from a player perspective, he respected that Mike Shanahan was honest about the situation (unlike for example the Haynesworth situation where he failed him on his physical two days in a row to show him who was the boss). Shanny says he needs to evaluate Rex Grossman and John Beck to see if the team needs to draft a QB early in the draft next year.
But I think that's stupid because he's giving Rex Grossman the start. Rex Grossman is in his 9th season (and John Beck is only one year younger, even though he's in only his 4th NFL season), so I think we know what to expect out of him by now. Furthermore, I don't think you go into the draft planning to draft whichever QB is still available at your pick. You need to evaluate them and decide whether they have the traits to succeed at the NFL level, and then decide whether that QB can help your team more than whatever other players might be available (a franchise left tackle or a shutdown corner, for example).
You've also managed to piss off the fans, who get 3 additional weeks of what you've told them amounts to an exhibition. And a lot of the players aren't happy either. You think Santana Moss (a 2011 free agent) is happy with the chance of having his stats (and therefore his future contract offers) depressed because Grossman's the QB?
I think Shanahan's losing control of this situation, and I may be wrong, but I get the feeling that all of this is happening so that he can put his son (Offensive Coordinator) Kyle in position to succeed. I don't think it's going to work, especially if they draft a QB. QBs take a couple years to be ready, and by 2012, Shanahan may be fired or resigned (and Kyle discredited).
The only reason I don't blame McNabb for his crappy year is that he is surrounded by old guys and some very old guys and he had a pretty nice year last year with good talent around him. It wouldn't surprise me at all if he bounces back on a team like the Vikes or Cards
Originally posted by BigDaddyLocoThe only reason I don't blame McNabb for his crappy year is that he is surrounded by old guys and some very old guys and he had a pretty nice year last year with good talent around him. It wouldn't surprise me at all if he bounces back on a team like the Vikes or Cards
(edited by BigDaddyLoco on 18.12.10 1146)
I agree wholeheartedly. In fact, Donovan is also surrounded by one of the worst starting kickers (Gano, go home) and a bad offensive line. Then the defense gets hurt and all you have left is a quarterback stuck in a bad situation.
I love my Skins, but I will never support Sexy Rexy. I even hope they lose to my least favorite team in history, the Cowboys, just to prove how terribly run this organization is.
"Put on your helmets, we'll be reaching speeds of 3!" "It was nice of you to give that dead woman another chance." "All right, look alive everybody...oh sorry Susan."- MST3K: Space Mutiny Click Here (myspace.com)
I have a hard time believing that any AD's have said that. But really even if a couple of them have, what bearing does it have on Marshall playing a horrible schedule this season? Can you justify them being ranked based on who they've played?