I could praise this for the fact that Tegan and Sara in the Top 40 twice, along with Keane, Travis, Trail of Dead, Ted Leo, and the insanely awesome Arcade Fire. I could mock this for having Coheed and Cambria, Perfect Circle (twice!), Bright Eyes and Rise Against in the bottom 40. But since my sister is dating the lead singer of Fall Out Boy, I'll just say I want to see them on top of the bottom 40 for all time :)
Sorry, Coheed guy's voice annoys me. Plus they kinda suck. I believe the Long Island Press put it best when they called C&C "Rush for the Fuse Network" or something similar. And I'm tired of A Perfect Circle's boring, plodding songs, at least this go-round. It sure was all downhill after "Mer De Noms". Bright Eyes, well...no. He just doesn't do anything for me. And Rise Against I usually don't mind, but "Give It All" does nothing for me, and what the hell kind of album title is that? "Siren Song Of The Counter Culture"? YEAH MAN, YOU'RE TOTALLY INTO POLITICS. AND SCREAMING. And I'm not sure why you'd want Fall Out Boy that low if your sister's dating the lead singer, but if I were you, I'd hope it lasts, since if people around here are any indication, they're gonna break big with their next album. They're the next Taking Back Sunday! You heard it here first! Unless someone else has said that.
So I bought this album as a result of Amazon's promotion, and it is, in a word, AWESOME. Much more highly recommended than the first album I recommended in this thread. Here is a video of them playing on a recent NPR 15-minute concert: