The W
Views: 98322663
Main | FAQ | Search: Y! / G | Calendar | Color chart | Log in for more!
21.8.14 0718
The W - Music - Does "American Idol" count as Music ? (Page 2)
This thread has 14 referrals leading to it
Register and log in to post!
Pages: Prev 1 2(2677 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
User
Post (38 total)
WyldeWolf1
Boerewors








Since: 20.6.02
From: Florida

Since last post: 4368 days
Last activity: 4368 days
#21 Posted on
I can't believe my wife got me watching this....

I'm pulling for Justin to win this one. Why? He fits the mold of the kind of pop star that can actually be entertaining. He has great stage presence, looks like he's having fun, and has a great voice. I was just a tyke, but I can remember when Michael Jackson was worth watching, and Justin gives me that kind of vibe.

Kelly on the other hand, is so unbelievably vocally talented that pop music would be beneath her. I don't want to hear that voice wasted on cheesy crap.



See my avatar? That's what happens when I don't get my way.
dunkndollaz
Banger








Since: 3.1.02
From: Northern NJ

Since last post: 7 days
Last activity: 1 day
#22 Posted on
Kelly will be the bigger overall star but Justin - whose legion of cell phone wielding teenyboppers will dial until the fingers blister - will win the top prize.....and not only does he have a "Michael Jackson Vibe" - he also seems to have Michael Jackson's nose

Nikki is destined to be an episode of VH1's Behind the Music after her first CD sells moderately well, her 2nd CD bombs and her Playboy pictorial fails to generate any sparks



5 Time Wiener of the Day Runner-up
Tom Dean
Bockwurst








Since: 30.8.02
From: New York, NY

Since last post: 3243 days
Last activity: 2612 days
AIM:  
#23 Posted on
Hey A-MOL, watch it! :-) Kelly has legit talent. And I do think she will win. I think little girls love Kelly too, and everyone else prefers her by a wide margin.



Three Faces of Dean: Teenage Riot, T.R., and now this guy

"How YOU Doin'?"
- me, weekly (or so) at [slash]

"History is being make-ed... someone is going to get their head completely shaved off"
- David McLane, PPV opening promo

"Speaking of interfere and interference... right now, you're interfering with something... in my trousers." - DA FINK

Jubuki
Kolbasz








Since: 16.7.02

Since last post: 4329 days
Last activity: 4313 days
#24 Posted on
And, to answer the original question (no one else has): no.



Chris
The AIR RAID CRASH
count olaf
Goetta








Since: 15.7.02

Since last post: 3426 days
Last activity: 3422 days
#25 Posted on
I think and hope Kelly will win. She seems to be loved by all, having never been even close to being ousted. If they perform three or more songs apiece, she's going to blow Justin away.

I wonder what will happen next. Regardless of the outcome, Kelly, Justin, and Tamyra will probably drop albums sometime next year. Maybe Nikki as well. I wonder who will make it to album number three? Tamyra and Kelly I think. Everyone else fades off into the sunset.
WyldeWolf1
Boerewors








Since: 20.6.02
From: Florida

Since last post: 4368 days
Last activity: 4368 days
#26 Posted on

    Originally posted by Jubuki
    And, to answer the original question (no one else has): no.


Technically, humming two notes over and over is music. It's just not good music. Obviously, there is no original music, but that doesn't mean it isn't good performance-wise. The idea of songs being associated with specific singers (and not necessarily the ones who wrote them) is a relatively new one that arose along with the record industry in the twentieth century.

Yes, it is music. Is it good music? It's had its moments. Of course, that's entirely subjective.



See my avatar? That's what happens when I don't get my way.
dunkndollaz
Banger








Since: 3.1.02
From: Northern NJ

Since last post: 7 days
Last activity: 1 day
#27 Posted on
Nikki has now confirmed to EW that she used to work in a strip club in Fort Worth - I thought she looked familiar - guess this pretty much seals the deal on a future pictorial for her in Playboy.

Tonight I hope that Kelly blows Justin out of the water but pre-pubescent girls and their cell phones can be a fairly formidable force.

and does anyone else think that Justin looks like "Sideshow MEL" from the Simpson's ?

(Thanks for the correction - nice brain fart on my part)

(edited by dunkndollaz on 4.9.02 0837)


5 Time Wiener of the Day Runner-up
WyldeWolf1
Boerewors








Since: 20.6.02
From: Florida

Since last post: 4368 days
Last activity: 4368 days
#28 Posted on
Definitely not. He favors Sideshow Mel.



See my avatar? That's what happens when I don't get my way.
dunkndollaz
Banger








Since: 3.1.02
From: Northern NJ

Since last post: 7 days
Last activity: 1 day
#29 Posted on
Justin was his lounge lizard self and put on a good little show that was a little weak and tentative for the first half of his first song - Kelly, however, blew the doors off the Kodak Theater - wow - it would be a crime if she doesn't win

and AMOL - I can see the reason for your disdain of Pop Idol winner - Will - he looks like a chimpanzee and sings like Shaun Cassidy.



5 Time Wiener of the Day Runner-up
A-MOL
Frankfurter








Since: 26.6.02
From: York, England

Since last post: 3810 days
Last activity: 3752 days
#30 Posted on
The actual reasons are plentiful.

1) Will is obviously gay. The way he acts, talks, old pictures of him etc... it is obvious. He denies it for the entire competition. He wins and only comes out when the News Of The World threaten to do it for him with a former boyfriends story. It would not have hurt him, but the fact he lied pisses me off.

2) The result was fixed. Gareth was easily the favourite but suddenly, on the last night, Will gets 57% of the vote. People complain that Gareth's phone lines are blocked, which the producers put down to 'overuse'. Will's phone lines do not have this problem. He needed the push to sell the records as Gareth did not need the 'winner' tag as he was marketable straight away.

3) He has a lisp that really pisses me off.

4) His fucking god-awful version of Light My Fire.

5) Oh, and it was a class war in the end. Upper-class Southern England ponce (think Four Weddings) vs. young lad from the North who lived in a terrace house with his single mother (think Full Monty). The result is the exact opposite as any good Hollywood script would go.

By the way, everyone, look forward to World Idol! The winners of every countries competition meet to find who is the best.

Just shoot me.

(edited by A-MOL on 4.9.02 1644)


...full of energy. Multi-orgasmic, if you will, in a cosmic sort of way."
Y2Disco
Mettwurst








Since: 2.1.02
From: Pennsburg, PA

Since last post: 3748 days
Last activity: 3501 days
AIM:  
#31 Posted on
Figures. Another hometown boy gets held down.

Justin ruled. Maybe I'm just biased though, since his hometown is only a few minutes from mine.

In reality though, this is just like Tough Enough. Wasn't Nikki already offered a record deal?

//Edit: I'm dumb.

(edited by Y2Disco on 4.9.02 2206)


"If you like to fight girls so much, why don't you meet me in the ring?"
-Jeff Hardy
Tom Dean
Bockwurst








Since: 30.8.02
From: New York, NY

Since last post: 3243 days
Last activity: 2612 days
AIM:  
#32 Posted on
Good job, Kelly! She definitely deserved the win (after Tamyra was out, that is.) Too bad she apparently will have to record total crap music. Those prefab songs are fucking horrendous.



Three Faces of Dean: Teenage Riot, T.R., and now this guy

"How YOU Doin'?"
- me, weekly (or so) at [slash]

"History is being make-ed... someone is going to get their head completely shaved off"
- David McLane, PPV opening promo

"Speaking of interfere and interference... right now, you're interfering with something... in my trousers." - DA FINK

CajunMan
Boudin blanc
No longer registered








Since: 2.1.02
From: Give me a Title shot!

Since last post: 1036 days
Last activity: 173 days
#33 Posted on | Instant Rating: 0.00
I'm just glad the chick Kelly won. Maybe she will sign with Smackdown records?



http://www.trenchwarfare.net

http://www.trenchwarfare.net
Torchslasher
Knackwurst








Since: 17.1.02
From: New F'n Jersey

Since last post: 316 days
Last activity: 283 days
#34 Posted on | Instant Rating: 6.44
It shouldn't have been that close. 58% to 42% for Kelly over Justin. Thank God that good taste and sense won out over 14 year old girls voting 100 times each for Justin.

Tamyra was already signed by Simon's label. Nikki has been rumored, but I haven't heard for sure that she is signed (I hope not). Justin will be signed, but probably by whoever's label has NSYNC (even though the boy band phase has been...well...phased out).

Good job Kelly, and stay away from the other Idol winner.



"Oh would you stop being all stealthy and just get in the truck"- Tom Servo
dunkndollaz
Banger








Since: 3.1.02
From: Northern NJ

Since last post: 7 days
Last activity: 1 day
#35 Posted on
Simon actually has the options on all 10 of the finalists so no one can sign with anyone until he says they can. He will probably sign Justin and let Nikki walk. No other CD can be released until after Kelly's CD is released in late October / early November. Her first single comes out in two weeks and it will be that soon to be overplayed wedding song that she blew the doors off despite it being schmaltzy - "This Moment in Time".

I'm glad Kelly won - I don't think that any of this will go to her head. She has already said that she is buying her friend who entered her in the contest a 1969 Corvette



5 Time Wiener of the Day Runner-up
A-MOL
Frankfurter








Since: 26.6.02
From: York, England

Since last post: 3810 days
Last activity: 3752 days
#36 Posted on
The same deal was done other here, so one of the original finalists quit on 'health grounds' and signed a contract with another label. The guy who came 3rd, Darius, wasn' signed by Cowell becuase he didn't want to do, in his words, 'crappy covers' so he signed for another label and recently scored a self-penned No.1.



...full of energy. Multi-orgasmic, if you will, in a cosmic sort of way."
Tom Dean
Bockwurst








Since: 30.8.02
From: New York, NY

Since last post: 3243 days
Last activity: 2612 days
AIM:  
#37 Posted on
The British winner was on the show twice btw. I can definitely see how he inspires fear and loathing. He sounded like the guy from Herman's Hermits.



Three Faces of Dean: Teenage Riot, T.R., and now this guy

"How YOU Doin'?"
- me, weekly (or so) at [slash]

"History is being make-ed... someone is going to get their head completely shaved off"
- David McLane, PPV opening promo

"Speaking of interfere and interference... right now, you're interfering with something... in my trousers." - DA FINK

A-MOL
Frankfurter








Since: 26.6.02
From: York, England

Since last post: 3810 days
Last activity: 3752 days
#38 Posted on

    Originally posted by Tom Dean
    The British winner was on the show twice btw. I can definitely see how he inspires fear and loathing. He sounded like the guy from Herman's Hermits.


I'm telling you now - if Gareth had have won, America would be going ga-ga. Boyish face, spiky hair, little gap betweeen the front two teeth and (get this) a stutter. Apparently, women find the stutter adorable (?). Will just has a punching bag face.

Kelly is all over our news at the moment as well. She's pretty and has a good voice, something they did not seem to be able to find in the British girls. I might emigrate.



...full of energy. Multi-orgasmic, if you will, in a cosmic sort of way."
Pages: Prev 1 2
Pages: Prev 1 2Thread ahead: Country Classics channel
Next thread: Kathy Mattea
Previous thread: FIlter
(2677 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
Can anyone comment on Nevermore or Lamb of God? I'm not familiar with either. I think it's pretty sad that Van Halen Van Halen wasn't higher, and that SRV and Satriani were so low. Malmsteen deserves higher even though he's a one trick pony.
Related threads: "American Idol" - More...
The W - Music - Does "American Idol" count as Music ? (Page 2)Register and log in to post!

The W™ message board

ZimBoard
©2001-2014 Brothers Zim

This old hunk of junk rendered your page in 0.159 seconds.