Well, Brody was a legit "tough guy" but Goldberg allegedly has actual martial arts skills. In a "shoot" with rules and referees and such I'd have to go Goldberg via tap out. In a street fight it's tough to pick against Brody. Of course, Regal and Finlay wipe the floor with the both of them and still drink until the bar closes. IMHO.
I'll be cautiously optimistic, but I'll always remember that Vince Russo brought us a real good challenger for the prestigious title of "Worst WrestleMania Undercard Ever." WM XV had no good matches outside of Rock/Austin.