Okafor is 14/11 in his career, younger, and he didn't fail a physical in the past season. This seems like one of those Larry Brown falling in love, then out of love with a player situations. Chandler will probably be in his doghouse by Thanksgiving, while Okafor will be on a team contending for a division title.
Carmelo or Lebron or Dar....oh wait, never mind that last one. I don't want to hear any bullshit about a shared award, just your flat-out opinion on who the ROY should be. In my mind, it's Carmelo by a hair.