This link here takes you to a house show report on the Observer for 12.05.2004 Smackdown house show at Madison Square Garden. Pay close attention to the first line of the report where it shows the attendance. Isn't there something a little... odd about that, considering it's an MSG show?
6,000 to 6,500 for a Sunday afternoon house show isn't an awful figure in the current marketplace. This isn't the old days of MSG where the McMahon's would bang the place out with 22,000 plus every month. If they were doing that, they would book MSG every month for a house show, rather than just once every six months.
Hogan should have a higher grade. I mean c'mon, he's contantly gets the loudest pops everytime he steps foot into an arena, easily outdoing everyone. His skills have eroded a bit, but he can still put on a memorable match as Wrestlemania proved.