The W
Views: 99906643
Main | FAQ | Search: Y! / G | Color chart | Log in for more!
22.10.07 0134
The 7 - Baseball - Is this the case for the DH? Register and log in to post!
(991 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
User
Post (13 total)
Sec19Row53
Lap cheong
Level: 78

Posts: 143/1576
EXP: 4278115
For next: 104130

Since: 2.1.02
From: Oconomowoc, WI

Since last post: 1 day
Last activity: 3 hours
Y!:
#1 Posted on 29.8.02 1128.48
Reposted on: 29.8.09 1129.02
OK, I hate the DH as much as anyone, but my boss just posed this question, and I couldn't give him a good answer. Read the following, regarding Matt Morris' hamstring injury, then I have a question:
----------
ST. LOUIS -- Cardinals pitcher Matt Morris was placed on the 15-day disabled list Saturday because of a strained left hamstring, yet another blow to the St. Louis pitching staff.

Morris, a 22-game winner last season who is 15-7 this year for the NL Central leaders, hurt himself trying to beat out a ground ball Friday night. He left the game against Philadelphia after six innings.

"It was an idiotic play by me,'' Morris said. "I was just trying to beat out a routine out. Sometimes, I can't control that intensity when I'm in a game.''

Manager Tony La Russa had to agree.

"On that play, the worst thing he could do was try to leg out an infield hit,'' La Russa said. "It was stupid. I admire him, but it was stupid.''

There was no immediate word on how long Morris would be sidelined. Morris said he hoped to heal in about eight days.
------------
If a pitcher can't be expected to hustle on a meaningless groundout, does that mean that they've de-generated into nothing more than pitching machines, and we might as well have the DH? Without debating the pros and cons of the DH itself, can you deflect this argument somehow?

CLARIFICATION - I know that he should be able to hustle out a groundball. However, given that both he and his manager think it (i.e., hustling on a ground ball) was a stupid play, why should pitchers even bat? (And I still hate the DH)

(edited by Sec19Row53 on 29.8.02 1351)
Promote this thread!
rlbehan
Chipolata
Level: 25

Posts: 24/118
EXP: 85894
For next: 3727

Since: 6.7.02
From: Albany

Since last post: 3263 days
Last activity: 2046 days
#2 Posted on 29.8.02 1302.12
Reposted on: 29.8.09 1308.31
So, the logic here is that hustle is a bad thing, trying hard all the time is something that baseball frowns upon, that is "stupid" since in this case an injury occurred. No, this is not a case for the DH, it is just another sad commentary on MLB and its mindset. Overpaid and pampered players for the most part, and yet here is one who hustles, and is called stupid. Its not like the guy did something outside of his sport and got hurt.
mountinman44
Sujuk
Level: 63

Posts: 185/974
EXP: 2050216
For next: 46947

Since: 8.5.02
From: San Diego, CA

Since last post: 1250 days
Last activity: 1096 days
Y!:
#3 Posted on 29.8.02 1303.39
Reposted on: 29.8.09 1308.39
Considering that most modern pitchers do not hit for themselves from college through the minors, that's pretty much what they are reduced to. The National Leauge is the only one that mandates pitchers hit for themselves.
Pitchers, especially one of Morris' caliber, need to protect themselves from injury first. Hitting for most pitchers is a formality. There are pitchers, such as Woody Williams and Kevin Jarvis, who take their hitting very seriously, but most pitchers in the NL view it as a necessary evil.


(edited by mountinman44 on 29.8.02 1104)
redsoxnation
Scrapple
Level: 152

Posts: 100/7534
EXP: 43734110
For next: 567652

Since: 24.7.02

Since last post: 478 days
Last activity: 478 days
#4 Posted on 29.8.02 1451.30
Reposted on: 29.8.09 1453.01
Morris should learn from Manny Ramirez. He is a DH, and you never have to worry about him hustling on a ground ball.
WyldeWolf1
Boerewors
Level: 41

Posts: 314/361
EXP: 460455
For next: 19694

Since: 20.6.02
From: Florida

Since last post: 4430 days
Last activity: 4430 days
#5 Posted on 29.8.02 1532.30
Reposted on: 29.8.09 1559.04
If pitchers concentrated on hitting in the American League, then the DH would actually become more useful. See, the DH can bat for anyone, not just the pitcher. Therefore, pitchers able to hit would allow the team to use the DH to cover any defensive specialist.

I still hate the DH too.
Tom Dean
Bockwurst
Level: 50

Posts: 421/573
EXP: 913544
For next: 33780

Since: 30.8.02
From: New York, NY

Since last post: 3305 days
Last activity: 2674 days
AIM:  
#6 Posted on 29.8.02 1608.22
Reposted on: 29.8.09 1608.53
Actually, the DH does have to bat for the pitcher... good old Rule 6.10. Not that I really understand your point anyway... what makes you think it would be any easier for a pitcher to up his offensive game than a position players defensive specialist? Even Rey Ordonez has to concentrate on the defensive aspects of his game a lot less than a pitcher does.

Basically, though, what it boils down to is the incredibly high levels of skill that we're talking about to play modern major league baseball. In the old days of baseball, it was common for the best pitchers to also be the best hitters. And, the same is true today in Little League. But as you move forward in time, or move up the level of competition in the current time, the average player gets better, and the gap between the best and worst gets smaller. It is just incredibly unlikely that someone would BOTH be in the top .000001% of the population (or whatever) in the skills required to be a major league pitcher, and ALSO in the top .000001% (or whatever) in the skills required to be a major league hitter. Throw in that the pitchers practice pitching more than hitting for obvious reasons, and there is no real chance that there can be more than a handful of decent-hitting pitchers.
PalpatineW
Lap cheong
Level: 77

Posts: 298/1528
EXP: 4084042
For next: 107106

Since: 2.1.02
From: Getting Rowdy

Since last post: 2828 days
Last activity: 2671 days
AIM:  
#7 Posted on 29.8.02 1825.42
Reposted on: 29.8.09 1829.03

    Originally posted by rlbehan
    So, the logic here is that hustle is a bad thing, trying hard all the time is something that baseball frowns upon, that is "stupid" since in this case an injury occurred. No, this is not a case for the DH, it is just another sad commentary on MLB and its mindset. Overpaid and pampered players for the most part, and yet here is one who hustles, and is called stupid. Its not like the guy did something outside of his sport and got hurt.


No, no, no... The point is that Morris is incredibly valuable to the team - as a pitcher. It doesn't matter if he doesn't hit well, or doesn't try as hard to get on base. They don't expect him to. I think the point is that no one - players, managers, etc. - no one expects the pitcher to try their hardest at the plate. And it is foolish, because which do you prefer - a healthy Matt Morris pitching, or Matt Morris legging out a groundball and hurting himself?

And I think that was the point. If we all recognize that the pitcher's spot in the batting order is essentially wasted - and, indeed, that it's smarter baseball - then why even make the pitcher bat? It's like if an NFL was required to put an offensive player in a defensive arrangement every 9 downs, and, as a result, wound up forfeiting their chance each time. That's kind of a clumsy analogy, but there it is.
emma
Cherries > Peaches
Level: 87

Posts: 15/2086
EXP: 6365746
For next: 27053

Since: 1.8.02
From: Phoenix-ish

Since last post: 34 days
Last activity: 17 hours
#8 Posted on 31.8.02 0351.32
Reposted on: 31.8.09 0359.01
But the whole concept of the pitcher batting is one of the things that makes the manager's job interesting. It's got to be part of his strategy how to deal with weaker spots in the batting order, what to have the hitters ahead of the pitcher do, when to pull a starter to get some additional offence, etc.

Do we worry about our pitchers hurting themselves out there? You betcha. Randy Johnson running the bases is one of the most frightening sights ever. (I seem to recall a story about him tripping over 3rd base in a game, & sprawling flat on his face. He was fine, but rather embarrassed. Talk about panic in the dugout. However by the next day the guys had recovered sufficiently to lay out a chalk outline of a very tall body on the field where he'd crashed.) But Randy gets out there & plays the game -- the last game I was at, he got on base twice & got 2 RBIs, in addition to his complete game shutout.

It's just part of the game that everybody plays both offence & defence.

(Sorry that's not too concicely presented, but its late.)
darkdragoon
Bockwurst
Level: 49

Posts: 14/537
EXP: 829113
For next: 54776

Since: 26.8.02

Since last post: 3695 days
Last activity: 3695 days
#9 Posted on 5.9.02 2122.46
Reposted on: 5.9.09 2129.08
The case for the DH is having a guy who can hit, but might not be as good in the outfield as another guy who also should be in the lineup.

Or you've got a slugger and don't want him screwing up his hamstring on a flyball. Look at Bonds and especially Griffey Jr. for examples.

Or if you have 2-3 talented guys at the same position and you don't want to replace one.

(edited by darkdragoon on 5.9.02 1923)
J.T. Dutch
Pickled pork
Level: 32

Posts: 50/197
EXP: 189054
For next: 17390

Since: 3.1.02
From: SoCal 4 Life

Since last post: 2670 days
Last activity: 931 days
Y!:
#10 Posted on 6.9.02 0456.04
Reposted on: 6.9.09 0456.46
"And I think that was the point. If we all recognize that the pitcher's spot in the batting order is essentially wasted - and, indeed, that it's smarter baseball - then why even make the pitcher bat?"

... Why? Because that's one of the great nuances that makes N.L. Baseball great: EVERYONE has to hit -- you NEVER know who's going to be the hero -- it's not like Basketball or Football, where teams can keep going to the "money player" over and over again in the tough situations.

Knowing that the pitcher must bat affects how a manager composes his lineup. It affects the opposing manager's defensive alignment -- more specifically, how his team is going to defend against the sac bunt. Some pitchers are handier with the bat than others ... some can fake a bunt, then chop at a pitch and get the ball past a drawn-in infield -- some pitchers are so good that the manager can run-and-hit with them (Tom Glavine, Livan Hernandez, Greg Maddux, Mike Hampton), adding to an already attractive strategic tableau.

It's just an added skill that can come in handy ... like a pitcher who's a good fielder, or a left fielder with a good arm, or a shortstop who can hit for power, or a catcher that can run the bases well.

As for Morris hurting himself, it's just bad luck. Morris and LaRussa are only saying that it was "idiotic" or "stupid" because they're mad; they're frustrated because he got hurt -- it's only natural.

Of COURSE Morris should hustle -- what if the guy boots the ball and throws late to first? Then it's a great idea to run hard. If you want to get really technical about it, maybe he could have stretched his hams in the on-deck circle -- but, again, it's just bad luck. What if Morris is pitching and has to hustle off the mound to field a bunt (laid down by the opposing team's PITCHER, no less), and he hurts his hammy THAT way? Then what do you say? That it's "stupid" for him to try to make what could be a critical defensive play? Of course not.

(edited by J.T. Dutch on 13.9.02 0044)
chazerizer
Italian
Level: 34

Posts: 201/242
EXP: 252138
For next: 1516

Since: 11.7.02
From: Pittsburgh, PA

Since last post: 4389 days
Last activity: 845 days
AIM:  
#11 Posted on 13.9.02 0223.27
Reposted on: 13.9.09 0225.53
Plus theres an added element of strategy involved. Am I the only one who enjoys seeing a well executed double switch? I didn't think so.

Different topic, but I've gotta ask these questions anyway. Who is responsible for the graphic background in the middle of the forum, how did it happen, and why?
J.T. Dutch
Pickled pork
Level: 32

Posts: 52/197
EXP: 189054
For next: 17390

Since: 3.1.02
From: SoCal 4 Life

Since last post: 2670 days
Last activity: 931 days
Y!:
#12 Posted on 13.9.02 0306.28
Reposted on: 13.9.09 0309.43
"Who is responsible for the graphic background in the middle of the forum, how did it happen, and why?"

... I am. Sorry -- should be fixed now.
El Nastio
Andouille
Level: 90

Posts: 495/2228
EXP: 7181886
For next: 6750

Since: 14.1.02
From: Ottawa Ontario, by way of Walkerton

Since last post: 6 days
Last activity: 1 day
ICQ:  
#13 Posted on 13.9.02 1955.44
Reposted on: 13.9.09 1959.01
Well said Dutch.

I always liked the pitcher hitting because it adds that extra dimension. It's the 7th inning, you're down by one run. Your pitcher has been dominating BUT you need that run, the bases are loaded and there's two outs. No one is warming up in the 'pen yet, but you need that run. WHAT DO YOU DO?

I love that sort of stuff.
ALL ORIGINAL POSTS IN THIS THREAD ARE NOW AVAILABLE
Thread ahead: Manny gettin' high
Next thread: What's with the Monkey
Previous thread: Jose Lima
(991 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
The 7 - Baseball - Is this the case for the DH?Register and log in to post!

The W™ message board - 7 year recycle

ZimBoard
©2001-2014 Brothers Zim
This old hunk of junk rendered your page in 0.208 seconds.