BigDaddyLoco
Scrapple Level: 147
Posts: 670/5690 EXP: 38655559 For next: 782636
Since: 2.1.02
Since last post: 318 days Last activity: 318 days
| #1 Posted on 1.6.02 0249.30 Reposted on: 1.6.09 0259.01 | Well, might as well it's the 25th anniversery plus a lot of talent has passed through the ranks...lets take a look shall we. C - Dan Wilson 1st- Alvin Davis (I'm a die hard) 2nd- Harold Reynolds ( Boone has had one good year) SS- A-Rod 3rd- ??? (never had a solid man at the hotspot) OF-Griffey OF- Suzuki OF- Jay Buhner DH _ Edgar Martinez SP- Randy Johnson RP- Sasaki
Who didn't make the cut- Olerud, Tino Martinez at 1st, Mike Moore, Mark Langston at SP, Omar at SS, OF Dave Henderson, Phil Bradley, Danny Tartabull... Promote this thread! | | Eddie Famous
Andouille Level: 98
Posts: 195/2221 EXP: 9439507 For next: 214880
Since: 11.12.01 From: Catlin IL
Since last post: 2611 days Last activity: 2151 days
| #2 Posted on 1.6.02 0313.55 Reposted on: 1.6.09 0320.53 | Jim Presley at third....beats out Bill Stein...
No Tartabull at 2b? And where's the love for Tommy Paciorek? :) | cfgb
Bierwurst Level: 92
Posts: 454/1930 EXP: 7636413 For next: 120554
Since: 2.1.02 From: Ottawa, Ontario
Since last post: 562 days Last activity: 21 days
| #3 Posted on 1.6.02 1301.42 Reposted on: 1.6.09 1301.43 | How does Sasaki beat out Norm Charlton?
Mike Blowers at third?
Bret Boone has more than just one good year. Go back to 1993.
I'm pretty sure there HAS to be an outfielder more qualified to be an all time player than Suzuki - but I just woke up... | odessasteps
Scrapple Level: 139
Posts: 591/5065 EXP: 32464843 For next: 2684
Since: 2.1.02 From: MD, USA
Since last post: 3562 days Last activity: 3529 days
| #4 Posted on 1.6.02 1306.27 Reposted on: 1.6.09 1317.51 |
Originally posted by cfgb
I'm pretty sure there HAS to be an outfielder more qualified to be an all time player than Suzuki - but I just woke up...
Well Ichiro was the best player on a team that won 116 games. And he was MVP, in his first season in American basubaru.
Would you rather have someone who had a slighty above-average career for 4-6 years or someone who was spectacular for 1.25 years?
| BigDaddyLoco
Scrapple Level: 147
Posts: 672/5690 EXP: 38655559 For next: 782636
Since: 2.1.02
Since last post: 318 days Last activity: 318 days
| #5 Posted on 1.6.02 1520.22 Reposted on: 1.6.09 1520.35 | How does Sasaki beat out Norm Charlton?
Sasaki hasn't had the break down that Charlton has had. Charlton is part of those ledgendary Mariner bullpens that were famous in the late 90's, for blowing lead after lead.
3rd- I guess you could put Edgar there although his best years came after playing the position.
1st- Has had some solid players, but I don't know if one truely stands out. | cfgb
Bierwurst Level: 92
Posts: 455/1930 EXP: 7636413 For next: 120554
Since: 2.1.02 From: Ottawa, Ontario
Since last post: 562 days Last activity: 21 days
| #6 Posted on 1.6.02 1842.57 Reposted on: 1.6.09 1845.41 | Would you rather have someone who had a slighty above-average career for 4-6 years or someone who was spectacular for 1.25 years?
I'll take the above average guy because you DON'T know how Ichiro could wind up a year or two down the road. It's far too early for Suzuki - but that's me.
After all, Brady Anderson once hit 50 homeruns in a single season... | BigDaddyLoco
Scrapple Level: 147
Posts: 673/5690 EXP: 38655559 For next: 782636
Since: 2.1.02
Since last post: 318 days Last activity: 318 days
| #7 Posted on 2.6.02 0137.58 Reposted on: 2.6.09 0152.44 |
I'll take the above average guy because you DON'T know how Ichiro could wind up a year or two down the road. It's far too early for Suzuki - but that's me.
So pick your poison... | cfgb
Bierwurst Level: 92
Posts: 457/1930 EXP: 7636413 For next: 120554
Since: 2.1.02 From: Ottawa, Ontario
Since last post: 562 days Last activity: 21 days
| #8 Posted on 2.6.02 1426.37 Reposted on: 2.6.09 1429.01 | Alright, I just went looking through Seattle Mariners history.
They suck.
There is no above average outfielder shy of Jr. and Buhner.
Go with Ichiro. After reading that I almost want to cry for them. | odessasteps
Scrapple Level: 139
Posts: 596/5065 EXP: 32464843 For next: 2684
Since: 2.1.02 From: MD, USA
Since last post: 3562 days Last activity: 3529 days
| #9 Posted on 2.6.02 1436.15 Reposted on: 2.6.09 1438.06 | I think the next wave of outfielders would include Phil Bradley (who led the Mariners in Win Shares 3 years in the 1980s) and, already, Mike Cameron.
It is scary that it took them at least 15 years to get respectable, six or seven years later than the jays. | ALL ORIGINAL POSTS IN THIS THREAD ARE NOW AVAILABLE |
| | | | | | | | | |