The W
Views: 100274897
Main | FAQ | Search: Y! / G | Color chart | Log in for more!
31.10.07 1227
The 7 - Movies & TV - Walk the Line Register and log in to post!
(1020 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
User
Post (19 total)
skorpio17
Morcilla
Level: 52

Posts: 525/618
EXP: 1030025
For next: 53823

Since: 11.7.02
From: New Jersey

Since last post: 2417 days
Last activity: 2417 days
#1 Posted on 20.11.05 0906.02
Reposted on: 20.11.12 0907.23
since Harry Potter was sold out, I saw this instead and loved it. best movie I've seen this year. It shouldn't be compared solely to Ray, because Ray was a great movie as well. They both rocked.

The casting was great. Cash never had much of a voice so Phoenix does a good enough job here. Mangold has to be one of the most surefire 4 star directors with this Identity and Copland. He reuses Patrick well as Cash's SOB father.

The songs work well, only one missing is Understand Your Man. Even non-Cash fans should like this movie.
Promote this thread!
Crimedog
Boerewors
Level: 42

Posts: 251/374
EXP: 490529
For next: 30837

Since: 28.3.02
From: Ohio

Since last post: 2718 days
Last activity: 2708 days
#2 Posted on 21.11.05 0023.41
Reposted on: 21.11.12 0024.01
    Originally posted by skorpio17
    Cash never had much of a voice so Phoenix does a good enough job here.



Wow. Just...wow.
Stilton
Frankfurter
Level: 56

Posts: 677/793
EXP: 1397937
For next: 248

Since: 7.2.04
From: Canada

Since last post: 3191 days
Last activity: 3191 days
#3 Posted on 21.11.05 1257.09
Reposted on: 21.11.12 1258.06
    Originally posted by skorpio17
    Cash never had much of a voice so Phoenix does a good enough job here.


Whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa!

Maybe Cash never had much a voice in the American Idol, Simon Cowell breathing down your neck about being "pitchy" kind of way, but that is NOT what singin' a good old country tune is about.

When it comes to being emotive, when it comes to communicating something deeper than the words allow by themselves, when it comes to making a song come to life, there have been few voices in the same league as Cash's.
It's False
Scrapple
Level: 138

Posts: 1426/6026
EXP: 31434787
For next: 228273

Since: 20.6.02
From: I am the Tag Team Champions!

Since last post: 3 days
Last activity: 21 hours
#4 Posted on 25.11.05 0422.33
Reposted on: 25.11.12 0422.38
Saw the movie tonight and was absolutely blown away. Phoenix amazes, but Reese Witherspoon steals the show. She showed some great acting chops that I didn't even know she had and she's deserving of an Oscar nod for this one.

And know that if you see this movie, you'll be itching for the soundtrack. I know I was. Come for the wonderful portrait of Cash's life and enjoy little bonus moments like the appearences of Elvis's chili dog craving.
Mayhem
Scrapple
Level: 110

Posts: 2277/3648
EXP: 14291119
For next: 117813

Since: 25.4.03
From: Nashville, TN

Since last post: 2 days
Last activity: 2 days
#5 Posted on 25.11.05 2218.23
Reposted on: 25.11.12 2218.25

Fantastic picture. I wanted to get back in line to see it again. I currently live in Hendersonville, TN (& grew up close to there), so it was nice to see it mentioned in the film. I'm pretty sure I've been by that house as a kid.

I totally concur with the nod to Reese Witherspoon. She was fabulous (as was Joaquin).
StaggerLee
Scrapple
Level: 141

Posts: 2820/6351
EXP: 33614188
For next: 505910

Since: 3.10.02
From: Right side of the tracks

Since last post: 16 hours
Last activity: 13 hours
#6 Posted on 26.11.05 0131.17
Reposted on: 26.11.12 0131.18
Anybody who says Cash never had much of a voice, hasn't sat, half drunk and listened to SATISFIED MIND and shed a tear. The man can emote.

The man is in both the Rock and Roll AND the Country Music hall of fame.

Probably America's most underrated and overlooked musical force of the past fifty years.

I just saw this tonite. If Pheonix doesnt WIN the Oscar, then the fix is in. His transformation to Cash was astounding. I never thought he would be any good, since I pretty much hate him in every movie I have ever seen him in.

And, Reese should be at least nominated. She was truley suprising and amazing as June Carter.

I cant say enough about this movie. It was brilliant.

(edited by StaggerLee on 26.11.05 2220)
Parts Unknown
Lap cheong
Level: 81

Posts: 1407/1707
EXP: 4827312
For next: 165558

Since: 2.1.02
From: Darkenwood

Since last post: 59 days
Last activity: 52 min.
#7 Posted on 28.11.05 1355.12
Reposted on: 28.11.12 1355.21
    Originally posted by skorpio17
    Cash never had much of a voice so Phoenix does a good enough job here.


Dumbass.
oldschoolhero
Knackwurst
Level: 104

Posts: 2125/3059
EXP: 11580616
For next: 281549

Since: 2.1.02
From: nWo Country

Since last post: 1995 days
Last activity: 1929 days
#8 Posted on 28.11.05 1402.49
Reposted on: 28.11.12 1402.54
"I just saw this tonite. If Pheonix doesnt WIN the Oscar, then the fix is in."

Dude, I feel ya, but see Phillip Seymour Hoffman in Capote first. I'm not saying he's the sure-fire winner, but it's gonna be one Hella close battle.
Wpob
Lap cheong
Level: 81

Posts: 544/1740
EXP: 4793679
For next: 199191

Since: 21.11.02
From: Williston Park, NY

Since last post: 1 day
Last activity: 1 day
#9 Posted on 28.11.05 1439.45
Reposted on: 28.11.12 1447.16
    Originally posted by oldschoolhero
    "I just saw this tonite. If Pheonix doesnt WIN the Oscar, then the fix is in."

    Dude, I feel ya, but see Phillip Seymour Hoffman in Capote first. I'm not saying he's the sure-fire winner, but it's gonna be one Hella close battle.


After Fox's win for Ray last year, there is no way the Academy will give it to an actor playing a singer. I thought Phoenix was much better as Cash than Fox as Ray, but timing is everything. Look for Hoffman to win for Capote as he was off the charts awesome in this movie.
Crimedog
Boerewors
Level: 42

Posts: 258/374
EXP: 490529
For next: 30837

Since: 28.3.02
From: Ohio

Since last post: 2718 days
Last activity: 2708 days
#10 Posted on 28.11.05 2230.16
Reposted on: 28.11.12 2230.19
If Phoenix doesn't win, I'll be disappointed. If Reese Witherspoon doesn't win, I'll be scratching my head at the sheer lunacy of the Academy.
Tenken347
Boudin blanc
Level: 93

Posts: 846/2443
EXP: 7884788
For next: 168052

Since: 27.2.03
From: Parts Unknown

Since last post: 1 day
Last activity: 1 day
#11 Posted on 2.12.05 2242.23
Reposted on: 2.12.12 2242.39
Saw this last night. EVERYBODY in it deserves at least an Oscar nomination. The script and directing were okay, but the actors carried this film. I totally hope Waylon Payne gets a best supporting nomination and a WIN for playing Jerry Lee Lewis.

(edited by Tenken347 on 2.12.05 2043)
BigDaddyLoco
Scrapple
Level: 128

Posts: 1730/4975
EXP: 24017816
For next: 363950

Since: 2.1.02

Since last post: 1 hour
Last activity: 24 min.
#12 Posted on 2.12.05 2324.13
Reposted on: 2.12.12 2325.19
Witherspoon really nailed Carter's deep rumble
skorpio17
Morcilla
Level: 52

Posts: 527/618
EXP: 1030025
For next: 53823

Since: 11.7.02
From: New Jersey

Since last post: 2417 days
Last activity: 2417 days
#13 Posted on 3.12.05 1402.56
Reposted on: 3.12.12 1403.20
    Originally posted by Stilton
      Originally posted by skorpio17
      Cash never had much of a voice so Phoenix does a good enough job here.


    Whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa!

    Maybe Cash never had much a voice in the American Idol, Simon Cowell breathing down your neck about being "pitchy" kind of way, but that is NOT what singin' a good old country tune is about.

    When it comes to being emotive, when it comes to communicating something deeper than the words allow by themselves, when it comes to making a song come to life, there have been few voices in the same league as Cash's.


I wouldn't use "pitchy," but at least you get my point. I'd say his voice had a lack of range and color. He always sounded like an old man who had a hard life. He wouldn't make it far on AI.

I'm not much for the elitist Oscar awards and I don't think the man in black would be worried about them either. although the movie didn't direct itself.

Bottom Line: it is a great movie, worth repeat viewing.
Stilton
Frankfurter
Level: 56

Posts: 695/793
EXP: 1397937
For next: 248

Since: 7.2.04
From: Canada

Since last post: 3191 days
Last activity: 3191 days
#14 Posted on 3.12.05 1726.58
Reposted on: 3.12.12 1727.30
    Originally posted by skorpio17
    I'd say his voice had a lack of range and color. He always sounded like an old man who had a hard life. He wouldn't make it far on AI.


Oh, so sad. You sooooo do not get it. Not at all, I'm afraid.
Guru Zim
SQL Dejection
Administrator
Level: 139

Posts: 3591/6018
EXP: 32035576
For next: 431951

Since: 9.12.01
From: Bay City, OR

Since last post: 1 day
Last activity: 13 min.
AIM:  
#15 Posted on 3.12.05 1859.09
Reposted on: 3.12.12 1900.02
Saying JC wouldn't make it far on American Idol is like implying that "American Gothic" isn't a good painting because it isn't as colorful as a Rainbow Brite cartoon.

You don't have to be bright, poppy, and colorful to express emotion. Not everybody has to be a goddamn attention whore star spangled banner fuckup.
StaggerLee
Scrapple
Level: 141

Posts: 2832/6351
EXP: 33614188
For next: 505910

Since: 3.10.02
From: Right side of the tracks

Since last post: 16 hours
Last activity: 13 hours
#16 Posted on 4.12.05 0144.43
Reposted on: 4.12.12 0144.50

    Not everybody has to be a goddamn attention whore star spangled banner fuckup.


For some reason, that made me laugh for a solid minute.


ANYHOW, I would say Cash's voice was smooth, and expressive, instead of showy.

I cant imagine anybody else singing the Male part of "It Aint Me, Babe" or " 'Cause I Love You". (sorry, thats OLD SCHOOL Cash)

JustinShapiro
Scrapple
Moderator
Level: 131

Posts: 1229/5248
EXP: 26079326
For next: 345364

Since: 12.12.01
From: Pittsburgh, PA

Since last post: 17 hours
Last activity: 5 min.
#17 Posted on 4.12.05 1209.47
Reposted on: 4.12.12 1210.56

    I cant imagine anybody else singing the Male part of "It Aint Me, Babe"


Well shoot, I do know this one guy. He even sings the entire song. Not that I'm disagreeing with everyone in this thread except one's assessment of Cash's evocative voice.

As for the movie, it was, um, efficient how they minimized the story of Johnny Cash to that of a guy who obsessed over one girl and took drugs. But 'Spoon is where it's at; she deserves all of the awards for actressing.

(edited by JustinShapiro on 4.12.05 1328)
Crimedog
Boerewors
Level: 42

Posts: 272/374
EXP: 490529
For next: 30837

Since: 28.3.02
From: Ohio

Since last post: 2718 days
Last activity: 2708 days
#18 Posted on 4.12.05 1510.22
Reposted on: 4.12.12 1510.23
    Originally posted by JustinShapiro
    As for the movie, it was, um, efficient how they minimized the story of Johnny Cash to that of a guy who obsessed over one girl and took drugs. But 'Spoon is where it's at; she deserves all of the awards for actressing.

    (edited by JustinShapiro on 4.12.05 1328)


Well, let's call a spade a spade, here. That's pretty much Johnny Cash's life in a nutshell.

Reese Witherspoon was mind-blowingly good. And really, there were a lot of really, really good performances in this one. Waylon Malloy Payne (Jerry Lee Lewis), Dallas Roberts (Sam Phillips) and of course, Robert Freakin' Patrick were all awesome. And I loved the nice little bit of stunt casting with Shooter Jennings playing Waylon Jennings.

As for Cash's voice, go listen to "Sunday Morning Coming Down" and tell me that his voice doesn't have any range or color.
Freeway
Scrapple
Level: 110

Posts: 3123/3504
EXP: 14194999
For next: 213933

Since: 3.1.02
From: Calgary

Since last post: 313 days
Last activity: 1 day
#19 Posted on 5.12.05 1807.18
Reposted on: 5.12.12 1807.37
I finally got around to seeing this yesterday, and I was blown away. Very even-keeled look at the Man in Black, with excellent acting, use of music, and overall just a fantastic film.
ALL ORIGINAL POSTS IN THIS THREAD ARE NOW AVAILABLE
Thread ahead: X3 Trailer Is Here!
Next thread: FOX finalizes Spring schedule
Previous thread: Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
(1020 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
Related threads: Doom (SPOILERS) - Halloween Screams. - Gilmore Girls Thread - More...
The 7 - Movies & TV - Walk the LineRegister and log in to post!

The W™ message board - 7 year recycle

ZimBoard
©2001-2014 Brothers Zim
This old hunk of junk rendered your page in 0.243 seconds.