The W
Views: 100745788
Main | FAQ | Search: Y! / G | Color chart | Log in for more!
22.11.07 2237
The 7 - Baseball - Instant Replay?
This thread has 1 referral leading to it
Register and log in to post!
(335 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
User
Post (8 total)
jfkfc
Liverwurst
Level: 69

Posts: 570/1177
EXP: 2759168
For next: 110590

Since: 9.2.02

Since last post: 129 days
Last activity: 4 days
#1 Posted on 2.6.05 0819.39
Reposted on: 2.6.12 0820.46
Bobby Cox came out in support of instant replay (sports.espn.go.com) for at least tough home run calls, and Joe Torre agreed with him yesterday (nydailynews.com).

Not exactly earth-shattering, but still an interesting consideration. Selig, apparently, is against it, and the managers are half divided on the issue. Why not try replay for a season? Sure, baseball considers itself the last bastion of tradition (shyeah), but after putting interleague play in, as well as the All-Star Game winner/home field thing, shouldn't MLB be more apt to try these "new-fangled ideas"?
Promote this thread!
PeterStork
Sujuk
Level: 64

Posts: 373/1007
EXP: 2187227
For next: 26882

Since: 25.1.02
From: Chicagoland with Hoosiers, or "The Region"

Since last post: 72 days
Last activity: 4 days
#2 Posted on 2.6.05 1033.21
Reposted on: 2.6.12 1038.25
If replay were restricted just to fair-or-foul home run calls, as well as perhaps fan interference, I'm all for a trial. Just leave safe-or-out base calls and balls-and-strikes to the men in blue.
BigVitoMark
Lap cheong
Level: 76

Posts: 1503/1509
EXP: 3926913
For next: 79166

Since: 10.8.02
From: Queen's University, Canada

Since last post: 3408 days
Last activity: 3317 days
ICQ:  
#3 Posted on 2.6.05 1329.04
Reposted on: 2.6.12 1331.16
Agreed. I get the need for replay in the NFL, but the challenge system they have is abused. A potential game changing play, like a home run or a touchdown, fine, get it right. But if it's going to start nitpicking and drag the game to a halt on marginal plays, I don't want any part of it. I'd rather have an exciting game with the occasional human mistake than one that takes four and a half hours to play but gets everything right.
messenoir
Summer sausage
Level: 45

Posts: 310/449
EXP: 649337
For next: 10832

Since: 20.2.02
From: Columbia, MO

Since last post: 576 days
Last activity: 443 days
AIM:  
#4 Posted on 2.6.05 1828.10
Reposted on: 2.6.12 1829.01
And yet, with the limited amount of challenges allowed to each coach, it is their choice if they want to spend those challenges on small plays with the knowledge they might not have them for the big ones.

Also, big plays and small plays is all in the eye. I've personally seen more games hinge on whether a first down was attained or not then whether a big play suceeded or not. My personal opinion is that, with the amount of effort each player and team puts out on the field, this effort shouldn't be for naught because of a screwed up call.

I wouldn't mind seeing a system like the NFL, where each manager gets a limited amount of plays to review, so as to keep the game moving. Then, they get to decide whether to review a safe at first call, with the danger of not being able to review a foul or safe home run.
Eddie Famous
Andouille
Level: 90

Posts: 1191/2182
EXP: 7009197
For next: 179439

Since: 11.12.01
From: Catlin IL

Since last post: 364 days
Last activity: 358 days
#5 Posted on 2.6.05 1854.59
Reposted on: 2.6.12 1856.29
    Originally posted by jfkfc
    Why not try replay for a season? Sure, baseball considers itself the last bastion of tradition (shyeah), but after putting interleague play in, as well as the All-Star Game winner/home field thing, shouldn't MLB be more apt to try these "new-fangled ideas"?


No, because interleague play and the home field/all-star connection were both stupid.

As is instant replay in baseball. Leave it the hell alone.
Bullitt
Shot in the dark
Level: 85

Posts: 1448/1924
EXP: 5784932
For next: 113632

Since: 11.1.02
From: Houston

Since last post: 8 days
Last activity: 8 days
#6 Posted on 2.6.05 1931.15
Reposted on: 2.6.12 1932.11
Replay robs us the chance to make media figures out of morons like Jeffrey Maier and Steve Bartman.
jfkfc
Liverwurst
Level: 69

Posts: 571/1177
EXP: 2759168
For next: 110590

Since: 9.2.02

Since last post: 129 days
Last activity: 4 days
#7 Posted on 3.6.05 0553.31
Reposted on: 3.6.12 0559.01
    Originally posted by Eddie Famous
      Originally posted by jfkfc
      Why not try replay for a season? Sure, baseball considers itself the last bastion of tradition (shyeah), but after putting interleague play in, as well as the All-Star Game winner/home field thing, shouldn't MLB be more apt to try these "new-fangled ideas"?


    No, because interleague play and the home field/all-star connection were both stupid.

    As is instant replay in baseball. Leave it the hell alone.
Yes, lets go back to the tradition of yore, where pitchers tell the hitters where the ball will be thrown to, no helmets, no All-Star Games, ties, and day games only.

I agree that the All-Star Game winner getting home field idea isn't a great one, but interleague is enjoyable to a point. 6 Yankee/Met games are beyond overkill, and I would have had every fourth year having no interleague games, but I wouldn't call it a bad idea. Replay, for me, would work well if the managers (re Messenoir) had 2 challenges per game or so. I just figured that if half of the managers are calling for it, especially guys like Torre, Cox, and Alou, surely the idea has merit.
messenoir
Summer sausage
Level: 45

Posts: 311/449
EXP: 649337
For next: 10832

Since: 20.2.02
From: Columbia, MO

Since last post: 576 days
Last activity: 443 days
AIM:  
#8 Posted on 4.6.05 1038.26
Reposted on: 4.6.12 1040.33
I think we need to go back to the days when spit balls were legal. Hitters are too soft today.
ALL ORIGINAL POSTS IN THIS THREAD ARE NOW AVAILABLE
Thread ahead: The Dugout - MLB chat
Next thread: Big Names with small numbers - All Star Voting
Previous thread: Mark Prior breaks ptching arm
(335 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
Related threads: Yep, John Rocker is still is an asshole. - Swinging 3-0 - Selig proposes tougher Roids policy - More...
The 7 - Baseball - Instant Replay?Register and log in to post!

The W™ message board - 7 year recycle

ZimBoard
©2001-2014 Brothers Zim
This old hunk of junk rendered your page in 0.242 seconds.