Downtown Bookie
Morcilla Level: 58
Posts: 319/653 EXP: 1494001 For next: 83554
Since: 7.4.02 From: USA
Since last post: 2442 days Last activity: 2131 days
| #21 Posted on 18.8.04 1827.28 Reposted on: 18.8.11 1829.02 | IMHO reasonable arguments can be made regarding whether the President of the Unites States should be elected by using electoral votes from each state, or by the nationwide popular vote totals. While I have my own views on the subject, I believe that there is a more serious issue that should be addressed. If the U.S. is to continue to use the electoral vote system, then IMHO it should be used without the constitutionally created Electoral College. Quite frankly the concept of using human electors to vote for the President should be eliminated, and eliminated as quickly as possible. I believe that once a state's vote is certified, their electoral votes should automatically be cast for the candidate(s) using whatever system the state has in place (be it winner-take-all, by district, or what-have-you) without the use of the Electoral College. IMHO the continued use of human electors, who are free under the Constitution to vote for whomever they choose, is just asking for trouble. While only a few electors in recent history have cast their votes for a candidate other than the one they were chosen to represent (such as in 1976 (presidentelect.org) when one of Gerald Ford's electors cast his vote for Ronald Reagan, or in 1988 (presidentelect.org) when one of Michael Dukakis's electors cast his vote for Lloyd Bentsen) why continue to have a system in place that allows for a potential catastrophe? Because, believe me, if a Presidential election is ever decided in this century because a group of electors voted for a candidate other than the one to whom they were pledged, the resulting fall out will make the fighting over the 2000 election look like a love-in. | Grimis
Scrapple Level: 135
Posts: 3748/4700 EXP: 28678206 For next: 656875
Since: 11.7.02 From: MD
Since last post: 4704 days Last activity: 3158 days
| #22 Posted on 18.8.04 1935.02 Reposted on: 18.8.11 1937.43 | Originally posted by Downtown Bookie IMHO the continued use of human electors, who are free under the Constitution to vote for whomever they choose, is just asking for trouble.
Some states do restrict their electors by law to the candidates to which they committed.
Incidentally, we should not change this requirement for at least one very good reason. Horace Greeley was the Democratic nominee for President in 1872. He lost the general election, but died before the electors cast their votes. His electoral vote total was spread among four candidates, with the total of his VP candidate, B. Gratz Brown(who finished third overall in the Presidentail vote) was split among eight people.
If all electors were committed, they would be electing potentially a dead President, a dead Vice-President, or both. Imagine the chaos, for example, if under a must-vote system the winning ticket were elected, and then died in a plane crash the next day. A Majority of the other party existed in the House. At that point, you have a ticket winning an election, but a member of the opposite party serves the four year term. At least without a must-vote system, the winning party, under that doomsday scenarion, could coalesce behind a new ticket. | MoeGates
Boudin blanc Level: 100
Posts: 1685/2353 EXP: 10276958 For next: 77474
Since: 6.1.02 From: Brooklyn, NY
Since last post: 14 days Last activity: 7 days
| #23 Posted on 18.8.04 2136.23 Reposted on: 18.8.11 2136.24 | You wouldn't just vote in the dead guy, and then the V.P-elect would take office? | Grimis
Scrapple Level: 135
Posts: 3750/4700 EXP: 28678206 For next: 656875
Since: 11.7.02 From: MD
Since last post: 4704 days Last activity: 3158 days
| #24 Posted on 19.8.04 0646.02 Reposted on: 19.8.11 0647.00 | Originally posted by MoeGates You wouldn't just vote in the dead guy, and then the V.P-elect would take office?
If you vote in the VP, you can then select an alternate VP. Otherwise, you have to get it through congress. | ALL ORIGINAL POSTS IN THIS THREAD ARE NOW AVAILABLE |
| | | |