The W
Views: 98515863
Main | FAQ | Search: Y! / G | Color chart | Log in for more!
29.8.07 0926
The 7 - Random - ATI or nVidia?
This thread has 2 referrals leading to it
Register and log in to post!
(3659 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
User
Post (15 total)
ironcladlou
Potato korv
Level: 55

Posts: 425/701
EXP: 1261734
For next: 52464

Since: 2.1.02
From: Quincy, MA

Since last post: 2209 days
Last activity: 2061 days
#1 Posted on 10.3.02 2223.10
Reposted on: 10.3.09 2224.28
I just recieved approval from Mrs. Lou the other day to start buying parts to build my Athlon XP rig. Quite a step up from my Pentium 233. Here's the partslist so far:

Athlon XP 1500
Soyo Dragon Plus mobo
Antec black case and power supply (maybe)
30gb+ hard drive of some variety (prolly a 7200 RPM ATA100 drive)
CD-RW of some variety (definitely burn-proof, prolly 12x or higher)

Keep in mind, I'm being conservative here. I can always upgrade the proc later...I don't want to spend an assload of cash on this thing.

Here's my dilemma: I can't decide on a videocard. I don't play many 3D games, so pixel-shaders and polygons per second mean fuck-all to me, but I do want a card with TiVo-like Personal Video Recorder capabilities. I've narrowed it down to the ATI All-In-Wonder Radeon and the nVidia Personal Cinema. I'd consider the Matrox Marvel as well, but I haven't heard shit about it. Also, I'm talking about the older AIW Radeon, not the $400(!) AIW Radeon 8500. The purpose I intend to use this for is recording shows, then burning them to CDs in VCD format, to be played in my DVD player. Which card comes with the best software? If none have good software, can I use them with other software? How about picture quality? I JUST DON'T KNOW HERE, PEOPLE!
Promote this thread!
Addy
Bauerwurst
Level: 24

Posts: 52/105
EXP: 72974
For next: 5152

Since: 24.1.02
From: Melbourne, Aussie Land

Since last post: 4525 days
Last activity: 4522 days
#2 Posted on 12.3.02 0344.37
Reposted on: 12.3.09 0347.18
I do capturing myself, however, I've never heard of the nVidia Personal Cinema and Matrox Marvel. I don't know shit about any of the software that comes with them. Maybe you should check a review web site (try pcinsight.com). But I'll let you know what I use and see if that's what you want. I have a Leadtek Winfast GeForce3 card and a Belkin USB VideoBus II capturing device. It's a really small device. I suggest you check this little baby out! Click here Also, check out the review, click
here.


The software that comes with it is MGI VideoWave III. I don't find it to be that good myself, b/c it's shareware version and I can't figure out how to compress my files. However, I use a freeware software called VirtualDub.. I haven't captured anything from it yet, only came across it a few weeks ago (reading the help manual at the moment! There's a lot to read and teaches you all about capturing and all the jargon.) I don't think it will allow you to play them in your DVD player. But you better check with the VirtualDub guy. That's the best I can help you. Hope it helps.

PS: my computer-
Athlon 1.4GHz
Asus A7A motherboard
256DDR ram
IBM 40MB 7200rpm HD
Leadtek Winfast GeForce3
SB Live!
Ricoh CD-R/RW
Win98SE
cheap as dirt modem
and Medal of Honor kicks big ass!!!!!!!!!!

(edited by Addy on 12.3.02 0145)
ironcladlou
Potato korv
Level: 55

Posts: 451/701
EXP: 1261734
For next: 52464

Since: 2.1.02
From: Quincy, MA

Since last post: 2209 days
Last activity: 2061 days
#3 Posted on 12.3.02 0404.47
Reposted on: 12.3.09 0405.17
AFAIK, the Radeon All-In-Wonder, nVidia Personal Cinema and Matrox Marvel all do the same job, which is TiVo-like Personal Video Recording, aka, being able to pause live TV, being able to digitally record a show to one's hard drive, etc. Since I have a night job, I work when Raw and Smackdown are on, so I can't watch them. What I want to do is record them to my drive, burn them to a VCD (or burn them to a regular data CD in Windows Media, MPEG, or AVI format) and watch 'em at work. I'm not looking to get into hardcore video editing (right now, anyway). Just to clarify.

But thank you for the reply. I checked out a number of review sites, but none of 'em had a good head-to-head matchup between the ATi and nVidia cards (PC Insight didn't even have separate reviews of either card). I will take a look at that VideoBus thing...the way I see it, I don't necessarily need to get one of those cards, if I can get comparable hardware and the right software, I could essentially do the same thing. Thanks again for the help.
Addy
Bauerwurst
Level: 24

Posts: 53/105
EXP: 72974
For next: 5152

Since: 24.1.02
From: Melbourne, Aussie Land

Since last post: 4525 days
Last activity: 4522 days
#4 Posted on 12.3.02 0416.20
Reposted on: 12.3.09 0417.44
I know the VirtualDub saves in AVI. hey, it's free.

question: how can you watch them at work when you are suppose to be working? tsk!
ironcladlou
Potato korv
Level: 55

Posts: 453/701
EXP: 1261734
For next: 52464

Since: 2.1.02
From: Quincy, MA

Since last post: 2209 days
Last activity: 2061 days
#5 Posted on 12.3.02 0521.17
Reposted on: 12.3.09 0521.20
I hate having to say this all the time, but look at my post count. I have very little to do at work.
CRZ
Big Brother
Administrator
Level: 212

Posts: 530/16171
EXP: 140161061
For next: 874725

Since: 9.12.01
From: ミネアポリス

Since last post: 17 hours
Last activity: 3 hours
AIM:  
ICQ:  
Y!:
#6 Posted on 12.3.02 0654.33
Reposted on: 12.3.09 0659.01

    Originally posted by ironcladlou
    I hate having to say this all the time
ME TOO
Guru Zim
SQL Dejection
Administrator
Level: 139

Posts: 486/5999
EXP: 31669544
For next: 797983

Since: 9.12.01
From: Bay City, OR

Since last post: 20 days
Last activity: 20 min.
AIM:  
#7 Posted on 12.3.02 1300.37
Reposted on: 12.3.09 1301.23
Unless you do DIVX compression, I don't think you are going to be able to do RAW on one CD. That's two hours... on VCD that's going to definitely be two CDs worth.

DIVX takes a long time to compress. Does the video card do the compression real time as it captures?
MedallaGuy
Head cheese
Level: 39

Posts: 34/328
EXP: 403392
For next: 1383

Since: 12.1.02
From: San Juan, Puerto Rico

Since last post: 481 days
Last activity: 8 days
AIM:  
#8 Posted on 12.3.02 1509.49
Reposted on: 12.3.09 1510.29
Checked out the post and wanted to help.
First if you're gonna use it like a Tivo, wouldn't it be better to upgrade the HD to at least 60GB, they are dirt cheap right now. Also if you can cost in other things, why not get a DVD burner instead. VCD can only burn like 30-40 mins of good quality video...if you really want to create a good library at the same time, why not get the DVD-R.

As far as the video card...it seems that the old ATI is defenaitly the choice for you, since its like $250 cheaper, but again, no good bundled software is included from what i read. The nVidia seems to kick ass the most on the benchmark test.
Click Here

But...i just found out this new one from Creative Labs that i think it will suite you the best
Click Here

Allright hope i helped...good luck
ironcladlou
Potato korv
Level: 55

Posts: 455/701
EXP: 1261734
For next: 52464

Since: 2.1.02
From: Quincy, MA

Since last post: 2209 days
Last activity: 2061 days
#9 Posted on 12.3.02 2124.14
Reposted on: 12.3.09 2126.50
Guru: I believe the ATi card does MPEG-2 hardware compression. I don't know of any videocard that does DiVX hardware compression....besides, with CDRs being as cheap as they are now, two CDs is fine with me.

Medella: I think you were looking at the Radeon 8500 All-in-Wonder, not the 7500. The 8500 is $400, whereas the 7500AIW is $200. I ain't even considering the 8500. I checked out that Creative Labs card...looks interesting, but the copy is pretty vague about the specifications...is it a full-on videocard, or just a screen grabber? As far as an HD upgrade goes, 40GB should suit my needs fine for now...drives can only get cheaper. And a DVD Burner? Geez, wish I had $500 to spare. Maybe in a year when they're down around $200.
Addy
Bauerwurst
Level: 24

Posts: 56/105
EXP: 72974
For next: 5152

Since: 24.1.02
From: Melbourne, Aussie Land

Since last post: 4525 days
Last activity: 4522 days
#10 Posted on 12.3.02 2206.10
Reposted on: 12.3.09 2225.09

    Originally posted by ironcladlou
    Guru: I believe the ATi card does MPEG-2 hardware compression. I don't know of any videocard that does DiVX hardware compression....besides, with CDRs being as cheap as they are now, two CDs is fine with me.


I think the VirtualDub I posted earlier does DivX compression. I haven't tried it yet. I can let you know if you want.

Compressing in real time is not a good idea if you want good quality. You may lose frames doing this. And that's not good if you are capturing below 15fps.
ironcladlou
Potato korv
Level: 55

Posts: 456/701
EXP: 1261734
For next: 52464

Since: 2.1.02
From: Quincy, MA

Since last post: 2209 days
Last activity: 2061 days
#11 Posted on 12.3.02 2215.40
Reposted on: 12.3.09 2226.46
Yeah, but we're talking hardware DiVX compression here, not software. Hardware compression is a lot faster and a lot better quality.
Addy
Bauerwurst
Level: 24

Posts: 57/105
EXP: 72974
For next: 5152

Since: 24.1.02
From: Melbourne, Aussie Land

Since last post: 4525 days
Last activity: 4522 days
#12 Posted on 12.3.02 2248.18
Reposted on: 12.3.09 2249.15
silly me.........
MedallaGuy
Head cheese
Level: 39

Posts: 35/328
EXP: 403392
For next: 1383

Since: 12.1.02
From: San Juan, Puerto Rico

Since last post: 481 days
Last activity: 8 days
AIM:  
#13 Posted on 13.3.02 1527.21
Reposted on: 13.3.09 1529.02
Iron, if you check the test, the 7500 is included also, and i was talking about it...i think i saw it at $119 on the cnet compare shopping, the 8500 is defenaitly is way too expensive.

As for the digital recorder, here is the link to the creative labs page, they have all the specs that I think you will need to make your decision.
Click Here

I do also think there is no hardware that compresses directly to Divx...but sounds like something that would generate a lot of money...hmmm....later.
ironcladlou
Potato korv
Level: 55

Posts: 463/701
EXP: 1261734
For next: 52464

Since: 2.1.02
From: Quincy, MA

Since last post: 2209 days
Last activity: 2061 days
#14 Posted on 13.3.02 2215.41
Reposted on: 13.3.09 2221.57
I checked CNET...they only had the Radeon 7500, not the 7500 AIW listed. No love for ATi. I did manage to gind a pretty decent price for it on Pricewatch though.

Checking out the Creative card...yeah, that's definitely just a vidcap card...no video out or 3d acceleration. I don't wanna go that route, but thanks anyway. The Radeon has a better remote anyway...RF, so no line of sight is required.

My old boss at EB desperately tried to talk me out of buying ATi today. He told me to get a GeForce 4 MX. I reiterated my desire to do vidcap. He was fixated on that fucking GeForce card. I threw up my hands, and made my final decision...the ATi Radeon 7500 All-In-Wonder will be mine.
Mr. Cactuar
Chorizo
Level: 28

Posts: 64/147
EXP: 121015
For next: 10325

Since: 14.1.02
From: Cactuar Island

Since last post: 4045 days
Last activity: 4038 days
#15 Posted on 13.3.02 2343.47
Reposted on: 13.3.09 2345.07
You made the right choice. You want video editing with your games? ATI. You want just games? NVIDIA. Both are good choices, but the ATIs will always be more versatile.

Click Here
ALL ORIGINAL POSTS IN THIS THREAD ARE NOW AVAILABLE
Thread ahead: What's wrong with this picture?
Next thread: WWF Weakest Link - aka WWF2
Previous thread: Great Moments in the History of Mankind
(3659 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
The 7 - Random - ATI or nVidia?Register and log in to post!

The W™ message board - 7 year recycle

ZimBoard
©2001-2014 Brothers Zim
This old hunk of junk rendered your page in 0.237 seconds.