The W
Views: 99068453
Main | FAQ | Search: Y! / G | Color chart | Log in for more!
20.9.07 1110
The 7 - Guest Columns - Guest Shot Register and log in to post!
(618 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
User
Post (9 total)
Guru Zim
SQL Dejection
Administrator
Level: 139

Posts: 1532/6009
EXP: 31824097
For next: 643430

Since: 9.12.01
From: Bay City, OR

Since last post: 8 days
Last activity: 10 hours
AIM:  
#1 Posted on 8.5.03 0047.40
Reposted on: 8.5.10 0049.41
I have a dilemma. Someone submitted a guest shot to me, that, while overall is pretty good - it has parts that I don't really think are appropriaate.

So.

How would you guys like to see it? Edited? Censored? Ask the guy to take out the stuff, or just leave it and run it for you all to give feedback on?

I personally feel that part of it is tasteless, but since the piece is supposed to be a parody, it sort of makes sense for it to be.

//edit: dilemma. Spelling.

(edited by Guru Zim on 7.5.03 2353)
Promote this thread!
Excalibur05
Knackwurst
Level: 102

Posts: 1575/2925
EXP: 10760298
For next: 329707

Since: 19.1.02
From: Minnesota

Since last post: 34 days
Last activity: 2 days
AIM:  
#2 Posted on 8.5.03 0057.02
Reposted on: 8.5.10 0057.38
I don't know how much my opinion is worth, but I'd say ask him to re-write the offending parts. If it needs to be offending to be funny, it's probably not worth the post.

I'm not big on censorship, but if you're going to be screening for columns here you should have some standards on what should and should not be "appropriate".

I guess it really depends on what was said, but I'd first tell the person to try to find a better, more people friendly way to say what they were trying to say.

Wolfram J. Paulovich
Frankfurter
Level: 56

Posts: 236/742
EXP: 1330120
For next: 68065

Since: 11.11.02
From: Fat City, Baby

Since last post: 2923 days
Last activity: 2294 days
AIM:  
#3 Posted on 8.5.03 0138.11
Reposted on: 8.5.10 0139.13
I always bring it back to, "Yeah, but is it funny?"

I think in most cases, mocking the death of Hennig or Miss Elizabeth is tacky. But, if someone could find the one way in which taking potshots at it would be hilarious, I'd applaud them. Genocide is ugly, but Eddie Izzard made some good jokes out of it. If it's good enough to make me forget the horror of the reality underlying it, run that baby.

Then again, I would also worry about feedback. If you allow this person to break rules of decency in his column, will outraged respondents be able to use the same levels of vulgarity or offensiveness in their critiques? Will there be a double-standard? Is there an amenable and easy way to maintain the double-standard (i.e., lock the thread and direct everyone to P.M.)?
emma
Cherries > Peaches
Level: 87

Posts: 512/2086
EXP: 6343177
For next: 49622

Since: 1.8.02
From: Phoenix-ish

Since last post: 3 days
Last activity: 1 day
#4 Posted on 8.5.03 0457.28
Reposted on: 8.5.10 0459.01

    Originally posted by Guru Zim
    I have a dilemma. Someone submitted a guest shot to me, that, while overall is pretty good - it has parts that I don't really think are appropriaate.
It is perfectly reasonable for you to ask him to rework the problematic parts. If he doesn't mind doing that, then dilemma solved. If he doesn't want to change it, & you don't think it's appropriate, don't run it. I'm prefectly fine with having standards for the Guest Columns forum -- that is one of the things distinguishing that forum from the others. I've never seen any evidence that your judgement is overly restrictive -- I have no problem with your sensibilities driving the standards.
dMr
Andouille
Level: 89

Posts: 668/2212
EXP: 6853620
For next: 62308

Since: 2.11.02
From: Edinburgh, Scotland

Since last post: 11 days
Last activity: 1 day
#5 Posted on 8.5.03 1008.40
Reposted on: 8.5.10 1010.58
Depends what you mean by 'not appropriate'. If there's parts that appear designed simply to offend or upset then I'd ask the person to remove them.

If its just risque humour then I'm with Jeb. If its funny , its funny and I really dont see any boundaries with regards what is suitable material for comedy. I remember reading a column over here about how everything, no matter how tragic at the time, becomes fair game at some point in the future.

Either way, I'd give the guy the chance to remove offending items, or at least justify what he wrote before going for censorship.
asteroidboy
Andouille
Level: 91

Posts: 1357/2241
EXP: 7213778
For next: 255163

Since: 22.1.02
From: Texas

Since last post: 1396 days
Last activity: 304 days
#6 Posted on 8.5.03 1038.15
Reposted on: 8.5.10 1046.44

    Originally posted by Jeb Tennyson Lund
    Genocide is ugly, but Eddie Izzard made some good jokes out of it.


Yeah, but Eddie's brilliant, and I doubt that this author qualifies. But who knows.

If it's just making some tacky comment about a dead person, I say nix.
CRZ
Big Brother
Administrator
Level: 213

Posts: 2198/16221
EXP: 141145738
For next: 2221169

Since: 9.12.01
From: ミネアポリス

Since last post: 7 hours
Last activity: 7 hours
AIM:  
ICQ:  
Y!:
#7 Posted on 8.5.03 1200.07
Reposted on: 8.5.10 1201.47

    Originally posted by Guru Zim
    I have a dilemma. Someone submitted a guest shot to me, that, while overall is pretty good - it has parts that I don't really think are appropriaate.

    So.

    How would you guys like to see it? Edited? Censored? Ask the guy to take out the stuff, or just leave it and run it for you all to give feedback on?

    I personally feel that part of it is tasteless, but since the piece is supposed to be a parody, it sort of makes sense for it to be.

I either ran stuff verbatim, or I didn't run it.

If you feel you have to ask, you've probably already made the decision.
Cerebus
Knackwurst
Level: 108

Posts: 802/3459
EXP: 13378215
For next: 142328

Since: 17.11.02

Since last post: 4 days
Last activity: 22 hours
#8 Posted on 8.5.03 1324.58
Reposted on: 8.5.10 1327.23
Censorship is wrong. Just cause one person finds something tasteless doesn't mean everyone will.

Why not just run it with perhaps (at most) a warning. What is the tasteless part of said submission that is so bad?
Guru Zim
SQL Dejection
Administrator
Level: 139

Posts: 1533/6009
EXP: 31824097
For next: 643430

Since: 9.12.01
From: Bay City, OR

Since last post: 8 days
Last activity: 10 hours
AIM:  
#9 Posted on 8.5.03 1327.51
Reposted on: 8.5.10 1329.01
I've made my decision already. Thanks for the feedback.
ALL ORIGINAL POSTS IN THIS THREAD ARE NOW AVAILABLE
Thread ahead: Raw Booking Sheet-12/05/03
Next thread: SmackDown! (5/8/2003) Recap
Previous thread: SmackDown Booking Sheet-9/5/03
(618 newer) Next thread | Previous thread
The 7 - Guest Columns - Guest ShotRegister and log in to post!

The W™ message board - 7 year recycle

ZimBoard
©2001-2014 Brothers Zim
This old hunk of junk rendered your page in 0.203 seconds.